On 03/07/2011 15:19, Rob Seaman wrote:
Warner Losh wrote:

This mapping is both lossy (because you can't undo it unambiguously) and 
ambiguous (since the standard insists that leap seconds don't exist).
"Lossy" isn't quite the right word.  Unfortunately the only antonym offered for 
"idempotent" is "changed".

The point being that lossy compression may well preserve the essential content 
of some signal:

        http://arxiv.org/pdf/1007.1179

while mangling by POSIX does not.

Perhaps "irreversible"?  The mapping is surjective but not injective?  (Depends 
which mapping we're talking about.)  At any rate it is not bijective, not both one-to-one 
and onto.

Lossy is the right word here. It preserves most of the content of the signal (defined as an approximation of the value of time) at the expense of losing fidelity in some relatively rare events. It is analogous to jpg compression where one preserves the low frequency portion of the signal, but smears the high frequency components because the eye has trouble telling the difference.

Lossy is also more pejorative than "The function isn't 1-1 onto, so its inverse does not exist around the neighborhood of leap seconds." which is what I really meant by it. But that sounds so bland and boring, much like "UTC is continuous, but has a non-uniform radix." Easy to say, but it doesn't really convey the pain...

Warner
_______________________________________________
LEAPSECS mailing list
[email protected]
http://six.pairlist.net/mailman/listinfo/leapsecs

Reply via email to