On 19 Sep 2011, at 1446, Rob Seaman wrote:

> 
> If you don't believe that civil time is time-of-day where "day" means 
> "synodic day", then assert an alternate definition for what the word day 
> means.  Then we can debate the two alternatives head-to-head independent of 
> the complexity of how different deployed solutions will address the 
> requirements.

Clive's man on the Clapham Omnibus probably realises that timezones are a 
fiction, and are a discrete approximation to a continuous function (although he 
won't describe it like that).  He might have a dim memory from school of being 
told about towns having their own time and standardisation coming with the 
railways.   He'll be aware that sundials usually don't agree with his watch, 
and that when he crosses the channel the sun doesn't suddenly step in the sky.  
It might even have occurred to him that one reason the evenings are longer in 
Cornwall is that you're well to the west of London. Certainly, explaining those 
things is not difficult.  In America, or mainland Europe, where you can drive 
your car across a timezone boundary whilst looking out of the window, he'll be 
even more aware that they're an approximation.

Even if he doesn't know these things, English law's well-known "reasonable man" 
would not find it hard to understand that his watch ticking the same time in 
Norwich as in Penzance is a convenient way to make sure that he can turn the 
radio on in time for The Archers, but that the sun rises and sets at different 
times within that time zone.

Therefore, he'll be able to understand that he's already accepting up to two 
hours' disconnect --- one for the width of the time zone, one for daylight 
saving --- between civil time and solar time.  And he might even realise that 
his holiday home in Brittany (4' 20"W, UTC+2 in summer) is an even more 
dramatic example. 

So he's going to be pretty resistant to the idea that a few seconds a decade 
matters in the slightest.    Civil time is what his watch says.  He already 
knows civil time isn't solar time.  So shouting that there's a risk that civil 
time is going to unhitch from solar time by around a minute a century and the 
sky is going to fall isn't going to frighten him.

ian


_______________________________________________
LEAPSECS mailing list
[email protected]
http://six.pairlist.net/mailman/listinfo/leapsecs

Reply via email to