I can't make my mind up if this is a wind up or not. Assuming that you are serious, however incredible that might be from what you write, then I have a question. If Bates was not bringing MONEY to the club then what was he bringing ? He has nothing else that was needed nor wanted at Leeds. We did not need Bates to tell us what the situation was. We did not need Bates to tell us that we needed an injection of capital. What we needed WAS that injection of capital. If he did not have the capability then he should have stayed away. When he took over the club he took over RESPONSIBILITY for everything to do with the club at that point. He made himself chairman (I don't remember anyone being asked to agree) so YES it is ALL his responsibility. The football debts/contract payments were KNOWN when he took over. The rents and buyback arrangements on E Rd & TA were KNOWN when he took over. The contingent liabilities to bondholders were KNOWN when he took over. This summer was ALWAYS the target point in financial terms and the club needed an injection of cashflow to get us to this point in time. NONE of this was unknown and none of it is a surprise. Bates' only excuse could be something which was not known at the time and which nobody was expecting and which has surfaced since. Is there some such thing which needs to be taken into account ? Nobody went out (a la M&S) and asked Bates to come to Leeds as an employee because he was a turnaround specialist. He came of his own accord. The Kransortium made a few mistakes but their biggest mistake of all was handing over the club to Bates for stage two of the inevitable process out of the mess that the club was in. One other takeover candidate is also responsible, in a way, because he offerred too little to do the job (of taking over- NOT of taking the club forward). He got his tactics wrong and so effectively handed the club to Bates. There is no massive surprise in that both VAT and NI/income tax has to be handed over to HMRC. Everyone knows that surely ? This is not some tax on profits that we are talking about. Apart from employers NI (and that amount is also KNOWN), these sums owed are VAT which has been collected by the club from other taxpayers and payroll deductions from employees pay. It is NOT the clubs money in the first place, it forms no part of the clubs budget or budgeting, and the club has no right to spend it rather than hand it over to HMRC. Such action is taken KNOWINGLY and deliberately. Lastly, any takeover of the club, whether by the Supporters Trust or others, INCLUDES an arrangement with HMRC and at that point the responsibility for that arrangement passes to the new owners. If they don't keep to the arrangement then YES they are the ones who will get hounded (as you call it) by HMRC, and quite rightly so. Perhaps all that you are really saying is that Bates did not have the capability to do the job. In other words he bit off more than he could chew. Nobody asked him to take that bite and if he chokes on it then he only has himself to blame.
_______________________________________________ the Leeds List is an unmoderated mailing list and the list administrators accept no liability for the personal views and opinions of contributors. Leedslist mailing list [email protected] http://list.zetnet.co.uk/mailman/listinfo/leedslist The Leeds List - "where never is heard a discouraging word..."

