On Wed, 2007-05-23 at 09:25, Damian WALSH wrote:
> Can anyone explain (and I mean this as a genuine question..) the apparent 
> contradiction between the oft emailed assertion that Bates hasn't put any 
> money into Leeds with our assumption that the offshore trusts & companies are 
> a Bates front, yet they are owed (according to the list) 18M quid, 4,2M of 
> which was put into the club this year (or possibly this season, the posting 
> wan't entirely clear).

Let's say you run a business with a turnover of £10M but debts of £40M.
As a director, you have made certain guarantees to the bank as to the
viability of this company and have underwritten loans taken out by the
company with a call on your other personal assets.

One of your company's creditors decides that enough is enough - he wants
his money repaid now. You - or the company - haven't got that money. So
basically you are now at the point where the company could be pushed
into administration, and the banks will take the assets you used as
security against loans etc., quite possibly causing you personally
serious financial hardship and potential further problems should your
tenure in charge be deemed (either legally or by the business/banking
community) to be so reckless that you won't be allowed to run any other
businesses anytime soon.

Then a nice chap wanders up to you and says "Tell you what mate, I'll
take over your debts and reassign those loan notes if you sign your
company over to me for a quid." You're not over the moon because you're
losing the company - but at least you're keeping your house. 

So where would you find this altruistic "nice chap"? The answer is you
wouldn't. He would find you if he felt that your company had assets that
could be realised at some point in the future for significant gains -
and that in the meantime your company still had some decent cashflow to
keep the wolves from the door. The nice chap "speaks to" (sets up) a
couple of anonymous tax-efficient companies offshore which loan the
target company money to pay off some of its most pressing debts (quite
possibly by borrowings of their own), thus becoming creditors
themselves. After a decent interval has passed, the nice chap shrugs his
shoulders and says "Sorry, things have gone pear-shaped" and the company
goes into administration with all creditors - including nice chap's
offshore entities - getting a tiny fraction of their debts. However nice
chap says "I have faith in this company - it's just been burdened by
past problems" and buys the company out of administration for a very
small amount of money.

So it's now cost him the amount his offshore companies wrote off as
loans plus a small amount to buy out of admin, and he has a debt-free
company with decent cashflow - and he's done most of this without
actually dipping into his own wallet (he - or his offshore companies -
may have taken on loans which would need servicing but they've taken on
a few small interest payments now in anticipation of a large future
capital gain). Nice Chap is now in a position to take advantage of one
of the assets of the company - say, for example, the right to buy a
piece of land at below commercial rates - and develop that asset using
new borrowings (banks are always suckers for lending people money)
financed by the cashflow of the company as it continues its previous
activities (this wasn't a possibility for you because you'd already
maxed out your credit lines and nobody had faith in your ability to keep
the company going long enough to achieve such an outcome). Having
developed that asset - for example, building houses or a major
leisure/retail complex - nice chap then sells it for 10 times the amount
of money he put into the project in the first place and retires to spend
the rest of his days in some warm, sunny, low-tax location. Which was,
of course, his intention from the very beginning. 

All of the above is, of course, just an academic example of how a
debt-ridden, failing firm could be turned around by someone with a few
good ideas, excellent accountants and lawyers to ensure that every
loophole is exploited and no laws are broken, plus balls of steel to
ride roughshod over anyone who attempts to derail the plan. I have
absolutely no idea if there is one ounce of resemblance between any of
the above and what The Almighty Ken has done at our football club and
wouldn't dream of suggesting otherwise. However I'm sure I could dig up
a few examples in the commercial world (Canary Wharf?) where something
very adjacent to the above has happened.

j

_______________________________________________
the Leeds List is an unmoderated mailing list and the list administrators 
accept no liability for the personal views and opinions of contributors. 
Leedslist mailing list
[email protected]
http://list.zetnet.co.uk/mailman/listinfo/leedslist
The Leeds List - "where never is heard a discouraging word..."

Reply via email to