My view is that having no keeper on the bench was probably a justifiable risk with 3 subs but is less so with 5 subs.
Four places means you can have a defensive sub, a midfielder and 2 attacking options, that should be plenty. Given that we have some players that can cover a variety of positions - Telfer, Johnson, Hughes etc - i think we always should have plenty of flexibility. We dont seem to have 2 spare strikers at the moment anyway. Matt DAVID NATTAN <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:Anyway he did say something along the lines of it was harder to pick the 5 subs than it was the starting XI. This subs business was something me and my lads have discussed this season, namely is it worthwhile naming a sub keeper? Colin reckoned at Sheff U that it gained him lots more points having an extra striker on the bench and no sub keeper. He reckons his side dropped 3 points once when fatboy Kenny went off injured and the sub keeper let in a couple of goals that fatboy could have saved, but against that the ability to throw on an extra striker earned his side at the very minimum 12 points over the season. Given that Frazer is reckoned to be a decent enough keeper in an emergency and that we have a large squad does anyone else think Macca should go for it and leave Lucas out ? It would also have the advantage of keeping an extra squad player happy - the reserve keeper is presumably willing to pick up his wages without playing \ wait to get his chance whereas an outfield player who is not on the bench can soon become a problem - for example how long would it be before the likes of Hughes \ Douglas \ Johnson \ Kilkenny became disruptive and demanded a transfer if they did not get a place on the bench ? Just a thought Dave _______________________________________________ the Leeds List is an unmoderated mailing list and the list administrators accept no liability for the personal views and opinions of contributors. Leedslist mailing list [email protected] http://list.zetnet.co.uk/mailman/listinfo/leedslist "the morphine patch and the handfuls of dihydrocodiene and paracetamol did the business. I am GOING TO WEMBLEY !!!!" Dave Nattan May 16th 2008

