http://www.yorkshireeveningpost.co.uk/sport/Leeds-United-Thorp-Arch-was.5783254.jp
Leeds United: YEP Thorp Arch was deal too far
Published Date: 30 October 2009
By Phil Hay
Leeds United have restated their claim that they were unable to
independently finance the repurchase of Thorp Arch, citing the cost
involved in running the League One club.
In an interview with the Yorkshire Evening Post, chairman Ken Bates
moved to address concern among supporters over why United's income in
recent months and years was insufficient to secure ownership of the
club's training ground near Wetherby.
An exclusive buy-back option negotiated by Leeds when they sold Thorp
Arch to private owners in 2004 – a deal completed in an effort to fight
rising debts at Elland Road – expired on October 15 after a plan for
Leeds City Council to acquire the site and lease it back to United
collapsed in the final hours before the deadline.
Bates said the club considered the council's plan a "done deal" and
criticised the local authority for setting at late notice 13 conditions
which Leeds claimed they were unable to answer before the deadline and
would have left the club facing a £5.8million buy-back bill without a
guarantee that the council would provide the necessary funding.
The failed deal, however, raised questions about United's inability to
fund the repurchase cost themselves. The club posted a £4.5million
profit in the financial year leading up to June 2008 – including an
operating profit of more than £900,000 – and sold Fabian Delph to Aston
Villa in August for a fee which was widely reported to be in the region
of £6million.
United confirmed that the undisclosed fee for Delph was being paid to
them in instalments and said further income – generated by the likes of
tribunals involving a number of United's former academy players – were
being used to meet running costs and other expenses including managerial
appointments and sackings.
Among the liabilities listed by Bates were:
An annual wage bill in excess of £6million, described by him as "on a
par with an awful lot of Championship clubs".
A yearly rental bill of around £2million for Elland Road and Thorp Arch,
on top of £600,000 paid in rates and utility costs for the two properties.
Pay-outs which are currently being made to former manager Gary
McAllister and former assistant manager Steve Staunton, both of whom had
their contracts terminated in December of last year
Compensation owed to Blackpool Football Club after Leeds appointed Simon
Grayson as their new manager 10 months ago.
Investment of more than £500,000 in securing planning permission from
Leeds City Council to redevelop the East Stand at Elland Road.
Bates said: "This is an expensive football club to run and we didn't
have the money (to conclude the Thorp Arch deal without the council's help).
"The wage bill is on a par with an awful lot of Championship clubs.
"We've had to pay money to McAllister and Staunton and to pay for
bringing in Grayson. We've also spent £500,000 on getting planning
permission to redevelop the East Stand. When that's completed, it's
something the club will benefit from for years to come. Buying Thorp
Arch with our own money wasn't an option because we didn't have the
money to do it. A lot of clubs are in trouble at the moment but we're
run sensibly.
"Our objective at the moment is to get promoted from League One and
we're well on the way to doing that. Leeds United is run efficiently and
properly. Never again will this club be put in a position where it does
not live within its means. It's in safe hands."
Pressed on the subject of Delph's transfer fee, a portion of which is
being paid to the midfielder's former club Bradford City, chief
executive Shaun Harvey said: "You don't receive 100 per cent of the fee
up front.
"People see a headline figure of £6million but that's not what we
actually receive straight away. Bradford got their share and still have
some to come."
Bates revealed that Leeds would shortly be required to pay an
appearance-related sum to Barnet as part of the deal which brought
Tresor Kandol to Leeds from Underhill in 2007, and he also said that the
club were budgeting for additional bonus payments which would be due to
players signed on loan in the event that the club are promoted from
League One this season.
The profit of £4.5million recorded during the financial year leading up
to June 2008 arrived around the same time as Leeds incurred heavy costs
through their fight against a 15-point penalty, imposed on them by the
Football League following the club's exit from administration. Bates
confirmed that the bill for that fight ran to seven figures.
United's chairman said the accumulation of these costs explained why the
club were unable to raise the £5.8million needed to buy back Thorp Arch
from Barnaway Ltd, the company which holds the freehold on the training
ground and currently rents it to Leeds for around £500,000 a year.
He insisted that every one of the council's conditions would have been
met by the club had the local authority not raised them on the last day
before the October 15 deadline.
Bates expressed his disappointment with the council's failure to
conclude the sale, saying: "As far as we were concerned, it was a done deal.
"The conditions raised by the council at the last minute were all
capable of being resolved if it had given us enough time to do so but we
couldn't commit to a deal without the guarantee that the council would
come up with the money 28 days later (the point at which the sale would
have been officially completed). We didn't have the money to afford it."
Leeds no longer have the exclusive right to purchase Thorp Arch, though
the club's lease agreement runs for 20 years and they could still
attempt to negotiate a private sale with Barnaway Ltd at a future date.
In response, the council's joint leader, councillor Andrew Carter, told
the YEP: "The timescale for this wasn't set by us and we did our best to
meet it.
"Both parties worked in good faith to achieve a deal and, when it fell
through, we seemed to agree that everyone had done their best to make it
happen. But the conditions we stipulated existed all along."
_______________________________________________
the Leeds List is an unmoderated mailing list and the list administrators
accept no liability for the personal views and opinions of contributors.
Leedslist mailing list
[email protected]
http://list.zetnet.co.uk/mailman/listinfo/leedslist
http://www.worldnet.org.uk WorldNET2009