Excellent email. Sums it up perfectly. 


----- Original Message ----- 
From: [email protected] 
To: "Tim Leslie" <[email protected]>, "list leedslist" 
<[email protected]> 
Sent: Tuesday, December 22, 2009 4:22:08 AM GMT -05:00 US/Canada Eastern 
Subject: Re: [LU] Soton. 

Tim, I've been doing reasoned arguments on here for years and its got me 
nowhere. So I thought, for once why bother...the end result would be the same. 

If Beckford scores at OT the Beckford-haters will all just queue up to say 
"he's 
only doing it cos he's in the shop window", and if he doesn't score then it'll 
be all the usual "never shows in big games"...makes you wonder why he'd bother 
at all really doesn't it? So no I won't take your bet. But I still reckon that 
if we keep him (and currently the only reason he'd go is cos half the numpties 
"supporting" the team he plays for, think that a goal ratio of 2 in 3 is not 
good enough...does not prove that he works hard enough "for the team") then he 
will score more league goals this season than all of his forward line 
colleagues 
added together. 

Just a point about reasoned argument Tim, you can't say "we can't use the 
stats, 
the history" to judge a footballer. On that basis I propose our forward line 
for 
OT is Caspar and Hughesie because judging everything on what might happen and 
not taking any history into account, its about their turn to bag a few. 
Beckford's in a lean spell - the team hasn't been firing all around - missing 
Kisnorbo, Naylor, Higgs and Johnson - the midfield, not quite sure whether to 
play Kilkenny, Howson, Doyle - that doesn't make him a bad striker (at this 
level) 

Not every footballer has to charge around like a headless chicken to be 
effective (Tony Currie, Gary Lineker, Mark Viduka, christ even the blessed Lord 
Lucas of Radebe looked somewhat less than switched on sometimes). Sure every 
team needs workers, but not every player in the team has to be that kind of 
player. That doesn't mean that I don't think Beckford earns his goals, I think 
that forwards earn goals in different ways - Beckford makes the runs he thinks 
are worth making - not always for his own benefit, see the late header recently 
when he went up against the keeper to set up Gradel. It's just not appreciated. 

If it is "so easy" playing up front in the current Leeds Utd team that anyone 
could get the goals why don't they? Why is it only Beckford who does? I'll give 
you a list - Vokes, Kandol, Showunmi, Grella, Trundell, Becchio - why can't any 
of them match his strike rate? 

That header from 6 yards that Becchio missed on Saturday...Jesus if that had 
been Beckford half the crowd would have been after him. But because Lucciano 
runs himself into the ground he's somehow thought "easier to forgive". 

None of the above means Beckford is perfect, far from it, but I want to see 
Leeds Utd out of the third division and moving up and it strikes me that we 
have 
a much better chance of achieving that with a guy who is a proven goalscorer 
(and who puts the shit up the other team's defenders). We've only got one of 
those and its Jermaine. If he played for anyone else in this league we'd be 
coveting him something rotten. 

As far as speculation goes - I think he could probably do OK in the 
Championship 
and I hope that he does that with us next year. I don't think he has the 
temperament or touch to make it in the Premiership. 


On 21 December 2009 at 17:28 Tim Leslie <[email protected]> wrote: 

> Nothing like reading a reasoned argument ... then ignoring it and harping 
> on about a statistic eh Nick? 
> Let's take a good look at his record this season. 
_______________________________________________ 
the Leeds List is an unmoderated mailing list and the list administrators 
accept no liability for the personal views and opinions of contributors. 
Leedslist mailing list 
[email protected] 
http://list.zetnet.co.uk/mailman/listinfo/leedslist 
Volame vsechny Cechy 
_______________________________________________
the Leeds List is an unmoderated mailing list and the list administrators 
accept no liability for the personal views and opinions of contributors.
Leedslist mailing list
[email protected]
http://list.zetnet.co.uk/mailman/listinfo/leedslist
Volame vsechny Cechy

Reply via email to