https://bugs.documentfoundation.org/show_bug.cgi?id=143340
--- Comment #38 from stefan_lange...@t-online.de <stefan_lange...@t-online.de> --- (In reply to Telesto from comment #37) > (In reply to Miklos Vajna from comment #35) > > I'm afraid I don't have more thoughts other than the above comment 7 > > I might have some issues interpreting your comment. Are you only giving a > neutral observation. Or also entail a implicit conclusion, about which part > being the bug; resulting in comment 36 > > -> "keep ratio" can be a special value for width or height in case the other > axis has a fixed value. > > Means by example: height being fixed value, when width changes and visa > versa. > > -> "keep ratio" can be a view option, so if you enabled it for one image, > there is some effort to enable it for an other image as well, if you adjust > the width or height. > > Means: 'Keep Ratio' not being a image specific setting, but a general > setting. > It will apply for all other images in document; > > A) this is a kind of odd, because the other controls in the image dialog > apply to the specific image > B) Saving the Keep Ratio is not helpful in general. Assuming Keep Ratio > being set the default. Implying the intention is that the default applying > for each image individually until configured otherwise. This wouldn't work, > because it's turning Keep Ratio of for a single image would apply to all > other images. The default doesn't stick in the way the end-user would expect > (or at least me) > > I would see the point of saving it for each individual image. What MS Word > appears to be doing also; but not being supported by Writer. Would improve > document compatibility too. However no idea about the ODF side of the matter. > > In the mean time, in tend to opt for Keep Ratio being session only thing. > Disabled by default when opening a document. Re-using the previous state > (checked/unchecked) when modified during a session. So the same behaviour as > right now, except not saving the KeepRatio setting. -> In main this my opinion (see Comment 33) but I wouldn't disable this setting for images by default but enable it to not distort the images when measures are changed. Not to keep ration between width and height should be the exceptionel case - and when possible for only one call of the properties dialog. -- You are receiving this mail because: You are the assignee for the bug.
