https://bugs.documentfoundation.org/show_bug.cgi?id=174454

--- Comment #6 from luxhacker <[email protected]> ---
Thanks for your kind and speedy reply Heiko Tietze

I have checked also
[https://bugs.documentfoundation.org/show_bug.cgi?id=149372] of David Burleigh.
This is the same discussion ! And the remark of David Burleigh stating that
"This is for international meetings of a worldwide organization" is absolutely
justified.

1. Tools / Line numbering 
-------------------------

The existing Tools / Line numbering dialog box gives a good idea of how "global
paragraph numbering" should work. Both (global) line numbering and "global
paragraph numbering" should be viewed as if a secretary had added these numbers
after the document has been printed. 

These added line or paragraph numbers should not change anything on the layout
of the docuement. To discuss a document-draft, typically, you need them, for a
finished document, sometimes you supress them, but if the document is going to
be quoted often, you leave global paragraph numbers.

And believe me, no one wants a 100 page document to be reformatted after it has
been agreed upon !!!!!

2. Global line or paragraph numbers ?
-------------------------------------

It's a problem of *precision* and *avoiding information overload*. A paragraph
typically is an information block and when discussing a change, independently
of the size of the paragraph, you have to read the whole paragraph. With
linenumbers, you have some mental calculation to make ;) which is not the case
with paragraph numbering. 

Therefore, I *believe* that global paragraph numbering is a better idea. 

But you will find executives who prefer global line numbering...

3. What can be done
-------------------

3.1. To change the very least possible on odt specifications, you could
envisage to add a radiobox (instead of a tick-box) in the (global) Line
numbering dialog box. This will permit to choose between "global line
numbering", "global paragraph numbering" or "no global numbering".

This *should* be (I never looked in your code) a relatively limited
modification.

3.2. A little bit more user-friendly addition would be to add in the format
section dialog box a radiobox asking whether paragraph/line counting should be
done in this section. And also to permit to reset the global paragraph or line
counter to 1 (or whatever value).

3.3. Finally, the fully functional version could potentially include at the
paragraph level (both specific and style) a global line/paragraph numbering
tick-box

It seems (at least to me) that you will never have a reasonable use-case where
you need both global paragraph numbering and global line numbering.

And my suggestion would be to have a unique choice possibility at the (global)
Line numbering dialog box (see 3.1.). This is the only place where to choose
between global line or paragraph numbering.


4. Marketing
------------

At the risk of repeating myself, I strongly believe that if LibreOffice wants
to pursue its conquest of the world, it must be aware that large organisations
have often very curious habits. Perhaps the DocumentFoundation should think of
including optional attributes (if not already defined), of which this global
paragraph numbering is just a first example ;)



I post the present comment on my initial bug report
[https://bugs.documentfoundation.org/show_bug.cgi?id=174454] and on the one of
David burleigh [https://bugs.documentfoundation.org/show_bug.cgi?id=149372]. As
David's bug report was the first one, I suppose that you will close mine, and I
hope you will go on with a global paragraph numbering functionality.

Cheers

LH

-- 
You are receiving this mail because:
You are the assignee for the bug.

Reply via email to