https://bugs.documentfoundation.org/show_bug.cgi?id=170282
--- Comment #5 from Eyal Rozenberg <[email protected]> --- (Carrying over + adapting comments from the Telegram chat:) Elementary is massively superior to Colibre in my opinion - in Light mode. I like it as the default - it makes it easier for user to distinguish button functionality, as it is less abstract and uses color more than themes like Colibre and Sifr. Regarding the argument for consistency of icons across platforms/DE's - we don't even use a consistent UI toolkit, so I don't see why the icons have to be the same; and there's the matter of agreeing with the DE's overall style. But - if we were to choose a uniform icon set, then definitely Elementary for Light mode. As for Colibre vs Sifr in Dark mode... this is a bit of a tough call. Colibre uses colors, which I like in principle over monochromaticity. But for some icons, the color is limited to a small element and barely visible, e.g. the Track Changes icons, so it's more of a hint or aesthetic adornment; and the effective use of color is more tricky in Dark mode anyway. Sifr is close to being monochromatic (it also uses gray); but - it uses thicker lines, and better-pronounced/larger visual elements, than Colibre. -- You are receiving this mail because: You are on the CC list for the bug.
