Hi Wim, I looked at the score of the Menuet - I do not find anything extraordinary there. The Bass clarinet in B flat (Si b) is transposed as usual. I still do not understand what you mean by „German“ and „French notation“.
Thomas BTW: The French Horn parts (4 Corni) are also transposed, these are in F (french: Fa). > Am 29.01.2023 um 10:29 schrieb Wim van Dommelen <m...@wimvd.nl>: > > Hi Thomas, > > "Short" is a dificult concept.... > > I think the best is to point you to a live example, check entry PMLP255074 on > the (magnificant) IMSLP collection (do not hit print, this is bad for your > carbon footprint as the full score is 170 pages <;0). I myself looked at part > III "Menuette" (still 29 pages :-). Within the score look for the Bass > clarinet line and compare this score with the other instruments, both > concerning the pitch to play it as checking the key in which it is done. A > befriended professional player confirmed me this is "German notation". I'm > looking for help in converting this to the regular way of working. > > Regards, > Wim. > > >> On 29 Jan 2023, at 10:00 , Thomas Scharkowski <t.scharkow...@t-online.de> >> wrote: >> >> Hi Wim, >> >> could you provide short example? >> >> Thomas >> >> PS: I do not unterstand this sentence: << I want to play it properly >> notation (which is „French“ >> >>> >>> Am 29.01.2023 um 09:43 schrieb Wim van Dommelen <m...@wimvd.nl>: >>> >>> I encountered a piece written in so-called "German notation" and I want to >>> play it properly notation (which is "French" >>> >>> I can do the basic transposes but the key is always interfering and >>> produces strange results. >>> >>> Is there a quick Lilypond recipe to convert this (from "German" to "French" >>> written) ? >>> >>> Thanks, >>> Wim van Dommelen >>> >>> >> >
