Hi Werner, everyone else...
Oops, sorry...i didn't click "reply all"!
I also apologize for not searching the archive more thoroughly. Googgle
searches arent always the best thing...
Here are two examples from the score i'm working on now. The first one is
confusing because of the "sim" which is too close to the system below. (Yes,
I know i can tweak the position of it, and i will, but sometimes articulations
and expressions and markup can get really cluttered)
The second example, the "harm 12" and the ligature to the following note are
problems. (I will reposition the ligature to the top of the expression)
Neither of these are serious problems, but I'm sure you can imagine cases,
especially in contemporary, or more avant-garde music, where individually
spaced systems might very well be a concern.
A third example might be where, instead of spreading out the last few measures
to the very bottom of the page, (as per \paper { ragged-last-bottom = ##f
etc.) a printer might want to only spread out the systems to cover 2/3 of the
page, leaving room for text, images, etc, at the bottom of the page. i.e., a
final page might have only three systems instead of seven...this would look
weird if it were evenly spread all the way to the bottom.
Not a big deal, really, but there it is.
Thanks for all the help!
dirck
[cid:191e5338-025c-488a-862f-97ecd3f34827]
[cid:f31eba60-e224-4fd4-baa4-3049f382160d]
________________________________
From: Werner LEMBERG <w...@gnu.org>
Sent: Tuesday, May 21, 2024 1:34 PM
To: Dirck Nagy <dn...@uwlax.edu>; lilypond-user@gnu.org <lilypond-user@gnu.org>
Subject: Re: vertical spacing between systems for only part of a score
Caution: *External Email: Use caution responding, opening attachments, or
clicking on links.*
[Please always use 'reply to all'; I've now CCed the mailing list again.]
> >>> Here, I want to make 7 lines spread out to fill the entire last
> >>> page, but leave the other pages alone.
> >
> > Ah, I missed 'last page'. Perhaps all you need is
> >
> > ```
> > \paper {
> > ragged-last-bottom = ##f
> > }
> > ```
>
> the ragged-last-bottom = ##f does work in this case.
Good.
> I can see other uses for adjustable vertical spacing. Is there any
> other way to do it, on a "one system at a time" basis?
No, as mentioned in the thread. You should also look up the mentioned
issue to get more information. I also recommend to do some searching
in the 'lilypond-user' mailing list archive, which collects LilyPond
wisdom for more than 20 years...
https://lists.gnu.org/archive/html/lilypond-user/
> Any workarounds that you can think of?
The issue gives a work-around; there are certainly more available.
However, in general, it is a rather uncommon request – you shalt not
question LilyPond's vertical spacing decisions :-) To be serious: what
is your exact use case? In most cases it looks weird if the vertical
spacing suddenly changes.
Werner
