Hi Tina,

On 29/09/2026 14:28, Tina Petzel wrote:
This means that at the point you know something is on top of the page the 
layout is set in
stone — of course we could technically extend Lilypond to do even another 
spacing iteration
after page breaking, which is going to make things very much more complicating 
(we’d be
having pure-unpure stuff extended to 3 levels of pureness).

I don’t think that’s a reasonable length to go to, regardless of concrete technical implications. Artisan engravers didn’t use to make their page break decisions based on exact knowledge of where every single element of the page needed to go, rather they made a good approximation and later used their skill to make the page look good even if the fullness was somewhat outside the ideal. This means small adjustments to horizontal spacing, but also flexible placement of elements which don’t require exact alignment, like dynamics, slurs or text, even lyrics.

Dynamics and marks like the ones Kieren talked about in his reply are typical examples of elements that could and often did overlap with staff lines, sometimes using whiteout.

Best, Simon

Reply via email to