Hello,

tl;dr: why no multiple layout inheritance?

I'm trying to build a layout inheritance system. I'd like, for example,
layoutC to inherit from both layoutA and layoutB:

\version "2.27.3"

layoutA = \layout {
  \override NoteHead.color = "red"
}

layoutB = \layout {
  \override Stem.thickness = 10
}

layoutC = \layout {
  \layoutA
  \layoutB  % ERROR: bad expression type
  \override Stem.length = 20
}

\score {
  { c'4 d' e' f' }
  \layout { \layoutC }
}

Only one layout can be included, and it must be first.

I glanced at parser.yy (I'm no programmer). From what I understand, when
parsing a \layout { } block, LilyPond sets a flag at the start. Including
another layout (like \layoutA) is only allowed while this flag is set.
After the first item is processed, the flag is cleared - so a second layout
triggers "bad expression type".

Questions:
What is the rationale for allowing only one parent layout?
Could multiple includes be supported with "last setting wins" semantics?

Thank you,
*Pierre-Luc Gauthier*

Reply via email to