Hello List, it's been a while!

The specific use case is to typeset this Bach movement in a style similar to the NBA, that is, with up to four voices in the staff.

Setting precise positioning concerns aside for the moment (though they will be important eventually), I'm looking for a way to enter this into LilyPond ergonomically. The << ... \\ ... >> syntax doesn't seem to work with more than two voices, so my approach is to try and make something that behaves similarly (and hopefully also implemented similarly).

If you have other or better ideas, please suggest them! Otherwise, there are a few problems with my implementation.

%%%

#(define-syntax cond-list
  ;; Macro because exprs are not to be evaluated if the conditions are false
  (syntax-rules ()
   ((_)
    '())
   ((cond-list (cond . expr))
    (let ((c cond))
     (if c
      (let ((e expr)) (list e))
      '())))
   ((cond-list (cond . expr) rest ...)
    (let ((c cond)
          (r (cond-list rest ...)))
     (if c
      (let ((e expr))
       (cons e r))
      r)))))

voices =
#(define-music-function
  (a b c d)
  ((ly:music?) (ly:music?) (ly:music?) (ly:music?))
  (make-music
   'SimultaneousMusic
   'elements
   (cond-list
    (a . #{ \new Voice { \voiceOne #a } #})
    (b . #{ \new Voice { \voiceFour #b } #})
    (c . #{ \new Voice { \voiceThree #c } #})
    (d . #{ \new Voice { \voiceTwo #d } #}))))

\relative b' {
  \key b \minor
  \time 3/4
  \voices { fis'4 g fis8 e } { d4 d s } { fis,4 s cis' } { b,4 e a }
}

%%%

The first problem is that the function doesn't actually work syntactically if I want to omit one of the voices. Using e.g. \voices a g \default e substitutes the default value for the last two arguments and sets the e separately, and I can't use ##f explicitly because it doesn't pass the ly:music? check.

The second problem is one of efficiency: the function creates up to four new Voice contexts every time. The results don't look right if I create the contexts beforehand and use \context.

Any help will be appreciated!

Reply via email to