Hello David,
Thank you for clarify this, I was not aware of the {...} and << ... >>
propagation rules.
Chers.
Paul
24 oct. 2026 15:45:43 David Kastrup <[email protected]>:
> Paul Crabbe <[email protected]> writes:
>
>> Hello to all, I'm new to the list.
>>
>> When using temporary polyphony syntax, in a \relative notation
>> context, I stumble on a recurring problem : changing one note height
>> in one voice will affect octave positionnig on other voice :
>>
>> %========================================================================
>>
>> \relative c'' {
>> <<
>> {c e c g}\\
>> {c, c c c}
>> >>
>> }
>>
>> % changing last note on \voice 1 will move \voice 2 one octave up :
>> \relative c'' {
>> <<
>> {c e c g'}\\
>> {c, c c c}
>> >>
>> }
>
> Why wouldn't it?
>
> The propagation rules of \relative are basically:
> { ... } the last pitch in the set propagates as the reference outside
> << ... >> the last pitch in the set propagates as the reference outside
> < ... > the first pitch in the set propagates as the reference outside
>
> Apparently you are imagining yet another scheme
>
> << ... >> no propagation of relative pitch happens inside, every element
> inside starts with the outside reference pitch which presumably is also
> what gets passed outside unmodified at the end.
>
> Would be an idea, but that ship has sailed. Too much historic baggage.
>
> --
> David Kastrup