Yoshi,
Thank you for your endeavors and my behalf.
I shall apply your notation.
It just seems, iMHO, to be a rather complex solution for are rather simple 
occurrence.

Mark

-----Original Message-----
From: Yoshiaki Onishi <[email protected]> 
Sent: Wednesday, November 4, 2026 1:54 PM
To: [email protected]
Cc: [email protected]
Subject: Re: cautionary clef

Dear Mark,

> In the first alternative is a cautionary (non-functioning) bass clef.
>
> What is the notation for such?

So my intuition tells me that you should literally add a non-functioning bass 
clef, i.e. a text markup. But then the problem is normally such markups are 
placed above or below a note. Also because of that, you might run into the 
problem of not having enough space between the last note/rest and the barline, 
where such a clef would go. 

Given all that, I am piggy-bagging on David’s MWE (thank you!)

%%% BEGIN %%%
\version "2.26.0"

{
 \clef bass 1
 \repeat volta 2
 {
  1 \clef treble 1
  \alternative {
   \volta 1 {
    2 r4
    \afterGrace 6/10
    r4
    {
     s8
     -\tweak extra-offset #'(0 . -3.2)
     ^\markup { \musicglyph "clefs.F_change"}
    }
   }
   \volta 2  {  d'2  c'4 r4 \clef bass }
  }
 }
}
%%% END %%%

Extra-offset is for the vertical offsetting of the non-functioning bass clef, 
and as for the horizontal placement of it, you can tweak the denominator of 
\afterGrace.

Hope this helps,
Yoshi


-- -- --
Yoshiaki Onishi
https://github.com/yoshiakionishi/lilypond-snippets






Reply via email to