Thank you Werner and Mats for your replies. I apologize for my late response.

I don't really know how to create a minimal example, because it involves 
setting up the newer 2.4 LilyPond verses the previous2.22 version. I jumped 
directly from 2.22 to 2.26. I probably would have seen this issue if I had 
tried 2.24. I think that's when the "installation" changed. Prior to 2.24 
LilyPond files were located under a Windows ..\Program Files (x86)\ directory.

Werner, I have quite a bit of Scheme code to customize some things I do 
repeatedly. That code is in the .ily files that I mentioned. 

I have relocated things a bit. My LilyPond 2.26 is now located in:
C:\Users\John\LilyPond\lilypond-2.26.0\

My custom scheme code (.ily) files are located in:
C:\Users\John\LilyPond\Lilypond-Extensions\
I have never put then in the same location as LilyPond's own .ly files.

Previous Windows LilyPond versions (pre-2.24) looked under Windows 
..\VirtualStore\ for user include files. At least that's my understanding, and 
it has always worked for me.

I am currently able to run LilyPond, and it appears to find my scheme (.ily) 
include files. The problem now is that it can't find guile's ice-9 files. I 
have set the environment variable, GUILE_LOAD_PATH, to point to ..\guile\3.0\. 
But even before I set it, LilyPond appeared to figure it out on its own. I 
noted that when I ran "lilypond --verbose".

So, currently I'm stuck as to why LilyPond can't find the ice-9 files, even 
though it appears to find guile 3.0 successfully.
John

-----Original Message-----
From: Mats Bengtsson <[email protected]> 
Sent: Monday, November 9, 2026 2:58 PM
To: John Schlomann <[email protected]>; [email protected]
Subject: Re: Problem with 2.26.0 installation

>> I was having a problem in my 2.22.2 version on Windows 11.  Just in 
>> case it was a Lily bug, I installed 2.26.0. Now things are worse than 
>> ever.  The new Lily couldn't find my .ily files. I run Lily from a 
>> Windows .cmd file associated with file type ".ly".
> Please prepare a complete, minimal example that did work, and which no 
> longer works.
>
>> I've added a -I option in the script. This wasn't needed for my
>> 2.22.2 version.  Now it finds my .ily files, but still can't find 
>> other things including ice-9 modules and probably other things as 
>> well.  If I compile a simple test file that doesn't rely on other 
>> include files, it works, so I know it is able to run the lilypond 
>> binary.
> How did you set up the cmd->ly association?
>
>> I've installed 2.26 in %HOME%\lilypond-2.26.0\.
> So you just call `lilypond` on the command line, regardless in which 
> directory you are, right?
>
>> My .ily files are in
>> %HOME%\AppData\Local\VirtualStore\lilypond-2.26.0\share\lilypond\2.26.0\ly\.
>> Are there any environment variables or the like that tell LilyPond 
>> where to look for things? Or perhaps I have other installation 
>> problems.
I'm a bit confused here. In modern LilyPond versions, "installing" 
simply means unpacking a ZIP archive, so if you unpacked the ZIP archive in 
%HOME%\lilypond-2.26.0\, then LilyPond will look for its own internal .ly files 
in
  %HOME%\lilypond-2.26.0\share\lilypond/2.26.0\ly\
so you cannot expect it to look anywhere below %HOME%\AppData\ by default. As 
Werner already has pointed out, it's generally not a good idea to place your 
own include files within the installation directory. 
However, if you place them in some folder such as %HOME%\AppData\mylilyfiles\ 
or wherever, and then point to that folder using -I, then LilyPond should find 
them.
By the way, do you happen to have any spaces in the file path corresponding to 
%HOME%? That might possibly cause problems. If so, test to place them in a 
folder that doesn't have any spaces in the path.

    /Mats

Reply via email to