On Tue, 18 Dec 2007, Erez Zadok wrote: > In message <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, Hugh Dickins writes: > > In order to fix unionfs truncation, we need to move the lower notify_change > > out of the loop in unionfs_setattr. But when I came to do that, I couldn't > [...] > > Hugh, I want to understand how patches 3/4 and 4/4 are related. In patch 3 > you say "in order to fix truncation" but you mention a truncation problem > only in patch 4; is there a patch ordering problem, or they're both related > to the same issue (with 3/4 being a code cleanup, and 4/4 actually fixing > the problem)?
I needed to move that notify_change out of the loop, to fix the truncation problem, but had great difficulty understanding the loop. So, just as you say, made the code cleanup first in 3/4, then fixed the problem in 4/4. But that cleanup does need your review and testing. > > What tests did you conduct to tickle this truncation problem: I assume > fsx-linux through unionfs, mounted on tmpfs? Exactly. The familiar "fsx foo -q -c 100 -l 10000000" on its own is enough to trigger it, though my habit is to run that while forcing swapout and swapoff too. The problem isn't peculiar to tmpfs, but I expect other filesystems are more likely just to fail the fsx test rather than oops. > Did that include both series > of patches (your 9 tmpfs patches, plus the two memcgrpoup?). Any kernel without the unionfs 4/4 should show the problem, but differently with different sets of patches. A lot of my testing was with an earlier set of tmpfs patches for unionfs (I didn't realize the tmpfs 5/9 issue until later on), and with those it manifested as fsx failure. But if you run without any of these patches, I believe it manifests as shmem_writepage's BUG_ON(!(info->flags & SHMEM_TRUNCATE)); or its BUG_ON(!entry); Whereas in tmpfs 4/9 I removed that latter BUG_ON(!entry) - we don't usually bother to BUG on NULL pointers, just let the dereference oops. Hugh -- To unsubscribe from this list: send the line "unsubscribe linux-kernel" in the body of a message to [EMAIL PROTECTED] More majordomo info at http://vger.kernel.org/majordomo-info.html Please read the FAQ at http://www.tux.org/lkml/