On Tue, Jul 08, 2014 at 09:09:25PM -0700, Joe Perches wrote: > On Tue, 2014-07-08 at 15:25 -0700, Paul E. McKenney wrote: > > On Tue, Jul 08, 2014 at 03:05:16PM -0700, Joe Perches wrote: > [] > > > I still think the concept is pretty useless and it's > > > just a duplication of "M:", which isn't anything other > > > than a list of who should be sent patches. > [] > > It will be interesting to see how things go. > > Yes, it might work out fine and maybe might cause some > other beneficial changes. > > > There did seem to be > > some people who were comfortable being listed as RCU reviewers, but > > not as RCU maintainers. Perhaps the same thing happens elsewhere. > > Maybe so. > > I wrote a script to find which maintainer addresses that > haven't signed or authored a commit in the last 2 years.
Did you count Acked-by or Reviewed-by lines as maintainer activity as well? I do see a few cases of stale email addresses in there, for active developers who don't use the listed email address. Myself included (I don't use @freedesktop.org anymore, though it still works). I also see a few lists or role addresses: ceph-devel and [email protected] seem unlikely to author commits. > I got ~250 entries. That's about 1/4 of all maintainer > email addresses. > > Maybe a dozen of these are false positives though because > some maintainers prefer to receive email at one address > but ack from another. > > These are all lowercase for better matching. > > abhijit mahajan <[email protected]> > achim leubner <[email protected]> > adam radford <[email protected]> > al cho <[email protected]> > ali akcaagac <[email protected]> > allan stephens <[email protected]> > aloisio almeida jr <[email protected]> > andreas dilger <[email protected]> > andreas koensgen <[email protected]> > andrew hendry <[email protected]> > andrew veliath <[email protected]> > andries brouwer <[email protected]> > andy henroid <[email protected]> > anil ravindranath <[email protected]> > anil s keshavamurthy <[email protected]> > antoine jacquet <[email protected]> > antonino daplas <[email protected]> > armin schindler <[email protected]> > artur paszkiewicz <[email protected]> > "arvind r." <[email protected]> > ashley lai <[email protected]> > aurelien jacquiot <[email protected]> > balbir singh <[email protected]> > bill metzenthen <[email protected]> > bradley grove <[email protected]> > brett rudley <[email protected]> > brian johnson <[email protected]> > bruce chang <[email protected]> > bryan huntsman <[email protected]> > [email protected] > cesar miquel <[email protected]> > cezary jackiewicz <[email protected]> > chaoming li <[email protected]> > chen liqin <[email protected]> > chien yen <[email protected]> > chirag kantharia <[email protected]> > chris brannon <[email protected]> > christine caulfield <[email protected]> > christopher harrer <[email protected]> > "christopher li" <[email protected]> > christoph raisch <[email protected]> > cliff whickman <[email protected]> > colin leroy <[email protected]> > corentin labbe <[email protected]> > daniel drake <[email protected]> > daniele venzano <[email protected]> > daniel oliveira nascimento <[email protected]> > daniel ribeiro <[email protected]> > dario ballabio <[email protected]> > david kershner <[email protected]> > david rowe <[email protected]> > david safford <[email protected]> > david täht <[email protected]> > deepak saxena <[email protected]> > dirk eibach <[email protected]> > dirk opfer <[email protected]> > dmitry tarnyagin <[email protected]> > dominik brodowski <[email protected]> > doug gilbert <[email protected]> > doug thompson <[email protected]> > doug warzecha <[email protected]> > duncan sands <[email protected]> > "ed l. cashin" <[email protected]> > egor martovetsky <[email protected]> > eric biederman <[email protected]> > eric piel <[email protected]> > erik andren <[email protected]> > faisal latif <[email protected]> > ferenc bakonyi <[email protected]> > florian schilhabel <[email protected]>. > forest bond <[email protected]> > frank seidel <[email protected]> > fujita tomonori <[email protected]> > gary zambrano <[email protected]> > gilles muller <[email protected]> > gleb natapov <[email protected]> > guillaume ligneul <[email protected]> > guo-fu tseng <[email protected]> > gustavo padovan <[email protected]> > haavard skinnemoen <[email protected]> > hal rosenstock <[email protected]> > hansjoerg lipp <[email protected]> > hans ulli kroll <[email protected]> > harald welte <[email protected]> > harald welte <[email protected]> > henk vergonet <[email protected]> > henrique de moraes holschuh <[email protected]> > herton ronaldo krzesinski <[email protected]> > heungjun kim <[email protected]> > hideaki yoshifuji <[email protected]> > hoang-nam nguyen <[email protected]> > hubert feurstein <[email protected]> > "hung hing lun, mike" <[email protected]> > ian campbell <[email protected]> > ian molton <[email protected]> > ion badulescu <[email protected]> > ishizaki kou <[email protected]> > ivan kokshaysky <[email protected]> > jakub schmidtke <[email protected]> > "james e.j. bottomley" <[email protected]> > "james e.j. bottomley" <[email protected]> > "james e.j. bottomley" <[email protected]> > james morris <[email protected]> > "james r. van zandt" <[email protected]> > jamie lenehan <[email protected]> > jan-benedict glaw <[email protected]> > jan dumon <[email protected]> > jan harkes <[email protected]> > jan-simon moeller <[email protected]> > jarkko lavinen <[email protected]> > jarod wilson <[email protected]> > jason uhlenkott <[email protected]> > jaya kumar <[email protected]> > jaya kumar <[email protected]> > jay cliburn <[email protected]> > jean-paul roubelat <[email protected]> > jeff dike <[email protected]> > jens osterkamp <[email protected]> > jes sorensen <[email protected]> > jim paris <[email protected]> > jiri kosina <[email protected]> > jiri slaby <[email protected]> > joerg reuter <[email protected]> > joern engel <[email protected]> > johan hedberg <[email protected]> > john mccutchan <[email protected]> > john ronciak <[email protected]> > "john w. linville" <[email protected]> > jonathan buzzard <[email protected]> > "jon d. mason" <[email protected]> > jon nettleton <[email protected]> > josh triplett <[email protected]> > joshua morris <[email protected]> > joshua thompson <[email protected]> > juanjo ciarlante <[email protected]> > "juergen e. fischer" <[email protected]> > juergen stuber <[email protected]> > juerg haefliger <[email protected]> > kentaro takeda <[email protected]> > kevin curtis <[email protected]> > kevin hilman <[email protected]> > kirk reiser <[email protected]> > koichi yasutake <[email protected]> > kristoffer glembo <[email protected]> > kurt garloff <[email protected]> > leandro costantino <[email protected]> > len brown <[email protected]> > lennert buytenhek <[email protected]> > liam girdwood <[email protected]> > liam girdwood <[email protected]> > lior dotan <[email protected]> > "luis r. rodriguez" <[email protected]> > maik broemme <[email protected]> > manohar vanga <[email protected]> > marcelo henrique cerri <[email protected]> > marc hulsman <[email protected]> > "mark f. brown" <[email protected]> > martin mares <[email protected]> > matthew wilcox <[email protected]> > matt mackall <[email protected]> > maxim krasnyansky <[email protected]> > michael hanselmann <[email protected]> > michael petchkovsky <[email protected]> > michael reed <[email protected]> > michal januszewski <[email protected]> > michal ostrowski <[email protected]> > miguel ojeda sandonis <[email protected]> > mikael starvik <[email protected]> > mike marciniszyn <[email protected]> > mike rapoport <[email protected]> > miloslav trmac <[email protected]> > miroslav zagorac <[email protected]> > mitchell blank jr <[email protected]> > muli ben-yehuda <[email protected]> > nagalakshmi nandigama <[email protected]> > neela syam kolli <[email protected]> > nelson castillo <[email protected]> > nicholas a. bellinger <[email protected]> > nick piggin <[email protected]> > olav kongas <[email protected]> > olivier lorin <[email protected]> > pantelis antoniou <[email protected]> > pat gefre <[email protected]> > paul mackerras <[email protected]> > pau oliva fora <[email protected]> > peter chubb <[email protected]> > peter feuerer <[email protected]> > philip blundell <[email protected]> > philip kelleher <[email protected]> > philip moltmann <[email protected]> > praveen krishnamoorthy <[email protected]> > rakesh iyer <[email protected]> > ranganathan desikan <[email protected]> > remi denis-courmont <[email protected]> > riccardo facchetti <[email protected]> > richard l maliszewski <[email protected]> > "richard russon (flatcap)" <[email protected]> > rik faith <[email protected]> > robert gerlach <[email protected]> > robert love <[email protected]> > robert love <[email protected]> > rob herring <[email protected]> > roland dreier <[email protected]> > roland mcgrath <[email protected]> > ron mercer <[email protected]> > ron minnich <[email protected]> > samuel chessman <[email protected]> > santosh raspatur <[email protected]> > scott murray <[email protected]> > sergey lapin <[email protected]> > shane wang <[email protected]> > simon arlott <[email protected]> > simon kelley <[email protected]> > sorbica shieh <[email protected]> > srinivas kandagatla <[email protected]> > stefan eletzhofer <[email protected]> > stefano brivio <[email protected]> > steve french <[email protected]> > steve sakoman <[email protected]> > steve underwood <[email protected]> > steve wise <[email protected]> > subbu seetharaman <[email protected]> > sudarsana kalluru <[email protected]> > sujith thomas <[email protected]> > teddy wang <[email protected]> > terje bergström <[email protected]> > thibaut varene <[email protected]> > thomas dahlmann <[email protected]> > thomas winischhofer <[email protected]> > "tigran a. aivazian" <[email protected]> > tigran aivazian <[email protected]> > till harbaum <[email protected]> > tim small <[email protected]> > tim waugh <[email protected]> > tony finch <[email protected]> > tony olech <[email protected]> > torben mathiasen <[email protected]> > ulrich kunitz <[email protected]> > vegard nossum <[email protected]> > ville syrjala <[email protected]> > vishwas a deshpande <[email protected]> > vitaly bordug <[email protected]> > vitaly bordug <[email protected]> > wensong zhang <[email protected]> > willem riede <[email protected]> > willy tarreau <[email protected]> > "wong hoi sing, edison" <[email protected]> > xavier deguillard <[email protected]> > yokota hiroshi <[email protected]> > zhang wei <[email protected]> > zwane mwaikambo <[email protected]> > > -- To unsubscribe from this list: send the line "unsubscribe linux-kernel" in the body of a message to [email protected] More majordomo info at http://vger.kernel.org/majordomo-info.html Please read the FAQ at http://www.tux.org/lkml/
