There is a tool called emerge that can export all mail boxes from an
Exchange server to a PST. I used it about a year ago to migrate mail
boxes from one Exchange server to another.

I have a love hate relationship with Exchange, as a POP3/IMAP/SMTP
server it is the pox! For collaboration it is the best I have seen bang
for buck.

> -----Original Message-----
> From: CF [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] 
> Sent: Friday, 22 August 2003 12:49 p.m.
> To: Linux Users Group
> Subject: Re: Exchange server Re: Linux in schools
> 
> 
> On Fri, 2003-08-22 at 12:15, [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
> > Having used, installed and cofigured exchange quite a bit 
> in the past I can 
> > tell you that you are wrong on most counts below. 
> 
> :-)  I take it you've done this in a business setting.
> 
> > You can create individual PSTs from each user
> 
> Not for 1400 users I won't
> 
> , or configure each computer to 
> > maintain a local copy of their mail in order to move email 
> from one server to 
> > another,
> 
> Only about 12 staff have their own computer - the rest are 
> all shared. 
> So the old business idea of "One Person One Computer" just does not
> work.
> 
>  let alone backing it up and restoring it en masse between exchange 
> > servers.  PSTs can be imported into outlook regardless of 
> the user or their 
> > existing email configuration.
> 
> Outlook on P75s with 32 Mb ram?  That would be like expecting Jamie
> Olliver to make a cullinary masterpiece using a Macdonalds kitchen.
> 
>   Moving outlook mail to something else, ie 
> > Mozilla, is a little more complicated, but is do-able by 
> passing it into 
> > outlook express, then on to netscape / mozilla.  Other apps 
> exist for moving 
> > mail between other packages without resorting to individual 
> forwarding.
> 
> I think the question originally was more like "how do I move 
> EVERYTHING
> to some other mailserver"   Putting mail into a specific mail-reader
> application is not the end result required.
> 
> > Using Backup Exec with the exchange option you can delete / 
> restore individual 
> > emails to/from tape.  This is probably true for most decent 
> backup packages.  
> 
> Yes - but schools don't have much money....  and decent 
> backup packages
> cost a lot.  We're still using NT4 server cos its too much to 
> change to
> anything else.  Indeed - my four linux boxes are backed up using
> home-grown scripts.
> 
> > From memory the built in backup package in Windows 2000 
> server will not allow 
> > this, but then its not really a 'real' backup package 
> anyway (IMHO)...
> 
> See above - 2000 is far newer than anything running here.
> 
> > Exchange is prety misunderstood, and takes a lot of flak.  
> Its not really a bad 
> > package if you know how to use it (Something a lot of 
> people say about Linux, 
> > too :)
> 
> I retract my statement earlier about "festering.."  How about "simply
> totally unsuitable for schools" ?
> 
> > PS: I'm not a Microsoft advocate, but I hate to see people 
> shooting MS down 
> > without a full understanding of the product they are attacking.
> 
> I've never had any training on how to use exchange server - its too
> expensive.  Do you see the problem?  At least with an imap server
> running on a linux box I can ask google for help, and not come across
> the "hire an MSCE" stuff.
> 
> 
> > > On Fri, 2003-08-22 at 07:46, Terry Cole wrote:
> > > > With all the MS problems/virus as well as Exchange 
> problems I have been
> > > > having..
> > > 
> > > Others can comment on the rest, but since I have an 
> exchange server here
> > > and probably most of the problems you've had, I'll comment here.
> > > 
> > > Exchange is a festering heap of fertilliser.  There is no 
> way to move
> > > all the existing mail from ES to any other mailserver other than
> > > forwarding all email manually.
> > > 
> > > We have made a partial change - I run squirrelmail on the 
> webserver
> > > (linux) which is a webmail/imap gateway, and that runs 
> fairly well.
> > > 
> > > Users will loose all the 
> calendaring/schedualling/addressbook components
> > > of exchange server too, when you change to something else.
> > > 
> > > But then - its impossible to restore a single email from a tape
> > > backup... you have to restore the lot to a scratch 
> machine then forward
> > > it to the real server, so I have always told users to 
> save important
> > > emails to disk.
> > > 
> > > You might have to bite the bull's horns and change 
> wholesale, loosing
> > > the old mail... which is going to be a real turn-off for users.
> 
> 
> 

Reply via email to