Hi:
I have a couple problems using linuxptp with software timestamping  as a 
boundary clock when connected another PTP device on one of the interfaces, is 
the PTP grandmaster (better clock).

Background:
I have linuxptp version 1.5x running with software timestamping (2-step) and 
handling multiple network interfaces in an embedded linux environment.   When 
all interfaces are in MASTER port state, the PTP follow-up messages all have 
preciseorigintimestamp value that matches our  linux system time.


a)      My linux system time was off by a few hours when I introduced a PTP 
device with a better clock (class and priority1/2).  The BM algorithm does 
select the other  PTP device as the grandmaster, changes  that interface port 
state to UNCALIBRATED and then to SLAVE and updates our system time.  The 
process takes quite a while to complete (40 sec?), one issue is that our system 
time is lagging about 35 seconds behind the preciseorigintimestamp in the PTP 
master's follow-up message.  All the other interfaces (Master port state) on 
our switch start sending  our updated utc system  time  (with 35 second lag) in 
the preciseorigintimestamp of the follow-up messages and the grandmaster 
identity advertised is that of the better PTP master).  Any idea why there is a 
35 second difference in the preciseorgintimestamp of our follow-ups compared to 
the PTP foreign master's?    The preciseorigintimestamp in our follow-up 
messages, seem to use the linux kernel system time for software timestamp.

b)      If I introduce a large offset either by changing my linux system time 
or the PTP master's time (verified that preciseorintimestamp has large offset 
compared to our UTC/preciseorigintimestamp), linuxptp NEVER updates the system 
time and hence our preciseorigintimestamp has not sycnhronized to that of the 
PTP master.  There seems to be something fundamentally wrong here with my 
setup.  It appears the ONLY time I can get linuxptp to synchronize our system 
time to the PTP master is if I restart linuxPTP.   No further synchronization 
seems to be possible afterwards.

c)       I compared behaviour with other PTP devices and it appears that their 
system clock does NOT get synchronized to the UTC time in PTP sync/followup 
messages.  I've read that is usually the case for devices supporting hardware 
timestamping (separate clock maintained), but for software timestamping, I've 
read that the linux system time is synchronized by linuxPTP because the 
timestamp is returned by the socket/kernel when a SYNC message is transmitted, 
and that timestamp is what is put into the preciseorigintimestamp field in the 
corresponding follow-up.

Any help or guidance would be appreciated
Best regards
Dennis
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
_______________________________________________
Linuxptp-devel mailing list
[email protected]
https://lists.sourceforge.net/lists/listinfo/linuxptp-devel

Reply via email to