Michiel,

I strongly disagree.

LISP's primary claim is separation of locator and identifier semantics. 
However, that separation is not perfect. If fact, one might argue that it is no 
more perfect that the separation that is achieved by an L3VPN.

If we were to sweep this detail under the carpet, the reader would figure it 
out for himself, and wonder about what else might be under that carpet.

                                                Ron


4. LISP Overview

   LISP is an incrementally deployable architectural upgrade to the

   existing Internet infrastructure, one which provides separation of

   location and identity.  The separation is usually not perfect, for

   reasons which are driven by the deployment philosophy (above), and

   explored in a little more detail elsewhere (in [Perspective], Section

   "Namespaces-EIDs-Residual").
The first bit is probably OK, the second one I think doesn't add much value 
here, apart from saying that "if you want to look at some imperfections, go 
here". I'd move it into a later section if you need to discuss it at all.

_______________________________________________
lisp mailing list
[email protected]
https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/lisp

Reply via email to