On Tue, 2011-02-01 at 15:50 -0500, robert mckennon wrote:
> believe it or not, I have never actually swapped out a hard-drive in a
> raided system.

We all have our first time with something at some point. No one was born
knowing or having done it all before ;)

> I have a HP Proliant ML350 G4p running RHEL 5.3  with a bad drive in a raid-5.

Assuming you have a HP Smart Array controller or some RAID controller.

> It says it's hot-swappable....  but is that the best practice, or
> should I shut down and then replace the drive?

If the machine is still running, usually the drive will already be taken
out of use by the  raid controller. Which if thats the case, red light
vs green, or could be another color on the drive in question. Then you
can safely remove the drive and add back a new one. If using HP Smart
Arrays can use the hpacucli to check status, make changes, etc to the
array while the machine is up and running.

If you want you can take it down. Though you might find yourself with
more than one bad drive going that route. I would just swap out the
drive now with a known good one. Let it do its thing, once its back in
use and you have a spare again. If you want to be really cautious and
can take down the server. Then a reboot can't hurt. It will
re-initialize controller and do a test on most all drives.

Last time I lost a drive for some reason it cause the server to lock up.
Though that was before any attempt to replace the drive. A reboot
brought the machine back up, but drive was still dead, and luckily just
that one. After that replaced the drive, and all has been well ever
since. So at times freakish things can happen, even though they
technically should not. I am running RAID 5 with 2 spares, so should not
have effected the server running, but did.

-- 
William L. Thomson Jr.
Obsidian-Studios, Inc.
http://www.obsidian-studios.com


---------------------------------------------------------------------
Archive      http://marc.info/?l=jaxlug-list&r=1&w=2
RSS Feed     http://www.mail-archive.com/[email protected]/maillist.xml
Unsubscribe  [email protected]

Reply via email to