> -----Original Message-----
> From: Göran Roseen [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] 

> True!
> I have been thinking all along as new requests for features 
> in the rolling file appender comes in; "This should really be 
> done with logrotate", a Unix tool that is specialized in 
> rotating log files.
> 
> Today I googled around a little, and to my astonishment I 
> realized that it seems like no one has made a windows port of 
> logrotate. Really strange!

The best I could find is rotatelog, which is written in Perl and therefore may 
run on Windows with the help of ActiveState Perl.
http://www.interhack.net/projects/rotatelog/

The main problem with this approach on Windows is that files open for writing 
are locked and cannot be renamed. On UNIX based file systems you can rename a 
file while it is locked and the application will continue to write to it. 
Typically after renaming the log file you would send the application a HUP 
signal to cause it to close the current log file and open a new log file with 
the original name. There is no standard way of signalling applications in 
Windows.

Personally I think that the current RollingFileAppender is too complex and we 
would benefit greatly from a more pluggable approach similar to the new 
implementation in log4j:

http://svn.apache.org/viewcvs.cgi/logging/log4j/trunk/src/java/org/apache/log4j/rolling/

At least with a plugin model it would be simpler for users to define their own 
behaviours when the out of the box solution does not fit.

Cheers,
Nicko

Reply via email to