Dear lutenists,

I took a closer look to the Attaingnant "La Magdalena" in the Heartz
edition. The 4th last bar (actually "mensur"!) in the tabulature
of the Basse dance is:

    |\  \\         |\
    |   |          |
 ___c___a_________________________
 |__d_____d__c__a__c____|__a___d__
 |__d___________________|__a______ ...
 |__a___________________|_________
 |___________c__________|__c______


And Heartz has also notated it just like that. I suppose this place
is so also in the original. Can anyone confirm that?

Anyhow, I definitely want to change the bass like this:

    |\  \\         |\
    |   |          |
 ___c___a_________________________
 |__d_____d__c__a__c____|__a___d__
 |__d___________________|__a______ ...
 |__a___________________|_________
 |______________________|__c______
             c

Any comments, opinions or "contrapositions"?  ;-)

Arto


Reply via email to