>> Is there anyone on the list with AP who would care to enlighten us >> muggles about what you hear?
dunno about AP, or even PP; play a note to me, ask me what it was, my reply is guesswork. I also have no clue about intervals. I can sing the ones I want, just, dont ask me what they were, I hate to use my fingers for counting in public. But, once I have an inner memory of some performance of a piece, mine own or a recording, I can usually sing it from memory at the precise pitch it was played when I heard it. Basically, I am singing along with the inner voice track. Curious all this business, the mind is clearly engaged for all of this but in different ways for each of us. -- Dana Emery To get on or off this list see list information at http://www.cs.dartmouth.edu/~wbc/lute-admin/index.html