> but i.e. means 'that is'. 

I know that.  otoh, perhaps my memory is incorrect.  I don't have the
original reference any more (too many books).  But Fowler's got only
an example w/o the comma (though Fowler's British, which is a different
bias than mine).  I'll probably take the commas off, now that I've had
to consider it...
  
> I have a green car, i.e. an Emerald Mica Miata. 
>  
> Is it really proper to say: 
>  
> I have a green car, that is, an Emerald Mica Miata. 
> ??? 
>  
> Sure seems like a comma is misplaced there.  If this really is the proper 
> way, it sounds like one of the few rules I will purposefully break.  The most 
> obvious one I don't follow is putting punctuation within quotes.  Obviously I'm 
> thinking like a programmer and don't want the damn punctuation in the quotes. 

depends on what the punctuation is (I also prefer most of it outside, where
it can be parsed properly ;-)

-- 
Thomas E. Dickey
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
http://www.clark.net/pub/dickey

Reply via email to