Georg Baum wrote:
Am Samstag, 16. September 2006 18:47 schrieb Abdelrazak Younes:

I don't need to know. I am just moving code around and this should just work. I am quite confident actually that it _will_ just work.

OK, suppose it works. Then there is still the problem that this is supposed to be a cleanup, but obfuscates the code for somebody who knows X selection better.

Such as you?

Georg, if you have a comment or an abjection, express it better please. I didn't committed because I know I can't test and I am counting of knowledgeable people such as you.

It is standard X terminology to request or clear a selection, so a sensible cleanup IMO would be to rename selectionRequested to requestSelection and selectionLost to clearSelection.

Well, this new method touch _nothing_ that is related with X11 (following my cleanup). It just returns the current selection. This method should work for any platform, not only X11.


The clipboard is a bit different, there we have an abstraction over windows and unix clipboards, so we don't need to follow either terminology too closely.

No need for X knowledge, just need someone who test if the selection works or not, that' all.

IMO you need X knowledge if it should be really a cleanup and not arbitrary code shuffling around.

I think that's an unfair comment Georg. If it is just a question of naming I am all ears. I've named that getStringSelection() because that's exactly what it does: return the current selection as a string.

Abdel.

Reply via email to