On 09.12.16 13:25, Jean-Marc Lasgouttes wrote:
> Le 09/12/2016 à 12:59, mn a écrit :
>> This setting dwells under a different Settings group named Look&Feel?
>> There I can only change the color of this solid line, not its thickness
>> or position.
>> And in my eyes the line itself is the problem, not its color.
> 
> I understand your arguments, but this is all we have now. I am not 
> completely sure of what a good UI (visible but not obnoxious) would be.
> 

Neither am I.
Visibility and aesthetics are clashing frequently. Not just in LyX.
Right now I guess there were several reasons we arrived at the current
situation. Either very good or congruent reasons or just by chance.
But I also guess that no-one has tested or adjusted all the color options:

-- for people with (color-)vision abnormalities
-- for consistency of metaphors and hierarchies
-- the balance of beauty and usability (they are quite ugly, but I
actually do not care about this much since I found them to be 'working'
up until now)

The above is not meant as a complaint.
Nor am I a qualified expert for color-vision or cognitive ergonomics to
remedy this observation.
https://wiki.lyx.org/Tips/ColorSchemes and another website list several
"themes" that are arbitrary, cool, or likeable.
And I agree that this might be justifiably of some lower importance.


on topic:
Among others, I see the following scenarios:

a) Entering the text, manually or via c&p: the line is a hassle, and
helpful at the same time.

b) Proof-reading the content: the line is hassle.

c) Proof-reading for compilation or formatting errors and tweaks: the
line is essential.


Note that c and much more so b for me are the most important and
outstanding reasons that LyX is superior to any other TeX editor out there.

Might it be better than the current options
– to allow for an option of differing text-background color for foreign
languages, (This is arguably very likely to conflict with all the other
background choices under Look&Feel. )
– and make this switchable via a shortcut and toolbar toggle?

The quick toggle is presumably easiest and most important, given that
all those color options are daunting already.

> Note that one can see whether the language at cursor position is 
> different from default by looking at the status bar.
> 

I didn't think of that within this scope.
This is indeed helpful but very limited.
Cursor position is unable to tell me the (is it correct?) extent of the
language declaration.

Mike

Reply via email to