> From: John Christie <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
> 
> 
> On Tuesday, January 21, 2003, at 01:50  PM, Eric D. wrote:
> 
>> (PS
>> the OS X implementation drives me nuts... it's rather a challenge to
>> figure
>> out which app I'll switch to if I type command-tab)
> 
> It is dead simple, look at the dock.  It highlights the app that will

But the problem is that the dock is rather useless to identify what app is
open. Unless you want to waste a whole lot of screen real estate on it the
icons are pretty small, and not well distinguished from the rest of the GUI
(the app switcher has very good contrast of icons vs. background, UNLIKE the
Dock).

> be switched to before one switches to it.  If you don't release the
> command key but keep tapping tab you can cycle through apps without
> switching to them.

This is a rather bizarre behaviour since one tab will take you to one app,
but two will take you to another, not logically related to the first
(position-wise on the Dock, or sequence-wise in the command-tab sequence).
It's better than nothing, but certainly could stand improvement.

> From: Mac Duff <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
> 
> On 1/21/03 12:50 PM, "Eric D." <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:
> 
>> Seems to me we had this whole yeah-nay Dock debate not too long ago.
>> 
>> My opinion: the Dock is pretty much useless in its current incarnation since
>> it's too limiting
>> 
>> Your opinion: the Dock is the best thing since sliced bread.
>> 
>> The pundits' opinions: all over the place. Some love it, some hate it.
> 
> LOL! Yes, we sure did. Although, as you put an actual (subjective) piece of
> anecdotal evidence behind your opinion, I'll try for a little more
> (subjective) substance than a slice of bread for mine:
>
> My opinion: the Dock is more capable than the Apple Menu and App Menu,
> combined.

It *is* the app menu from OS 9 with only a minor change.

Unfortunately, since it does not provide TEXT (this is an objective
criticism, arguably), it is not effective as a QUICK app switcher (ergo, the
need for the ASM). Holding your mouse over the icon is a waste of time since
you have to wait for it to appear, and it doesn't remain when you cycle
up-and-down the dock. The dock could be improved significantly by having the
text describing an icon appear instantly (no delay; delay optional), and
(much more importantly), once the text has appeared, that it remains, and
cycles through the icons, thereby instantly describing them, rather than
forcing you to wait for it.

I am a text-based computer user (as are _many_ other users, especially the
95%+ that use Winblows on a regular basis) and find icons and window clutter
irritating. The fancy graphics affiliated with the Dock distract from the
purpose of a computer and a GUI -- to be a tool without you knowing it's
there (e.g. its appearance if hidden, resizing if small... I've tried
_everything_ to make it work and it's just not a good solution... simply
put, it's a good idea that's poorly implemented). Thus, text lists (with
icons as aids) are useful and more efficient than a nice-looking but
distracting GUI.

A link was recently provided for someone who compared Winblows XP to OS X.
He also criticised the Dock for similar reasons.

> right to left with Shift-Alt-Tab. Plus, of all the app icons in the Dock
> that one may keep there as their tweaked arrangement, the ones that are
> launched have the arrow underneath. The dormant apps do not have the arrow.

This requires that you take the time to look at the Dock, and figure out
what's going on. I expect _that_ part of the GUI to be seamless and it is
not. Therefore, I will continue to argue that the ASM is an inherent
requirement to make the process of application switching on the Macintosh
superior to that offered by Winblows XP. If Apple ever bothers to apply some
engineering resources to the Dock's design, there's a chance they'll obviate
the need for the ASM.

> Anyhooters, I'm sure you know all that already :) You can still say the Dock
> sucks... For you.

And you can say it's the best thing since sliced bread (or, "the Dock is
more capable than the Apple Menu and App Menu, combined")... for you.

(& I'll say that the OS will not be as good as it can be without the ASM...
I've seen a number of people fall in love with OS X, _after_ I introduced
them to the ASM (because it introduces a measure of constancy, and, more
importantly, EFFICIENCY (OSes and GUIs haven't really evolved since System
0.97, Finder 1.3 in 1984... they've become fancier, and more robust, but the
fundamentals haven't changed))

L8r, Eric.


-- 
Mac Canada is sponsored by <http://lowendmac.com/> and...

Shop Canadian, visit Mantek Services          <http://www.mantek.mb.ca>
       Low Prices That Will Keep YOU and Your MAC Smiling

      Support Low End Mac <http://lowendmac.com/lists/support.html>

Mac Canada info:        <http://lowendmac.com/lists/mac-can.shtml>
  --> AOL users, remove "mailto:";
Send list messages to:  <mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
To unsubscribe, email:  <mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
For digest mode, email: <mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
Subscription questions: <mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
Archive: <http://www.mail-archive.com/mac-canada%40mail.maclaunch.com/>

Using a Mac? Free email & more at Applelinks! http://www.applelinks.com

Reply via email to