> Subject: Re: Gnutella Programs? > From: Mac Duff <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> > Message-ID: <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> > In-Reply-To: <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> > > On 5/26/03 11:21 AM, "Carlson" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > >> Your assertion that it's all about piracy is narrow-minded. I find attitudes >> like that are quite prevalent on this list and one of the reasons I don't >> contribute much. Maybe it's because we're a bunch of stuck up the you know >> where Canadians. And that is a downer. > > Okay. Show of hands, please: > > Who uses P2P apps like Hotline, Gnutella, Limewire, Acquisition, Drumbeat, > Kazaa (PC only app) or Morpheus (PC only) for the transferring of digital > creative content that YOU YOURSELF have CREATED and own, to a SPECIFIC and > secure server destination that ONLY you or authorized LICENSED persons have > access to, or backup your software installers in a similar fashion -- > despite the fact that CDR media is cheaper than underwear? > > Anybody...?
Me me me me. Please teacher, pick me. And, did I mention that I don't worry about secure server. I'm so grateful the genie is out of the bottle. Although, concentration of ownership is the norm in the era of the US military empire, at least P2P applications wrest control of content away from these extensions of the US military industrial complex and force them to make it more accessible. The notion that PPP will kill content creation is nonsense. Pure, utter nonsense. Pop music is of such low quality that it's laughable they want to be *compensated* for its production. They've had a formula which has worked for years but it's collapsing. Movie studios have hit on their own formula (and are starting to give us more and more pop-crap along the line of such memorable movies as that recent forgettable airline comedy starring some has beens about a stewardess who makes her way to the top... two hours of my life permanently *lost*) and DVDs offer much better bang for the buck (who wants to pay $20 for a lousy CD which *might* contain two or three worthwhile songs (of which a scant $1 or 2 might make it to the artist) when you can get a used (or sometimes new) DVDs for $15 which offer a full two hours+ of entertainment often including music?) PS While I'm on this rant, Apple has sort of got it right but not quite (there's no way in hell I'll pay $1.50 for a low-quality track). The flat-rate per song idea and no subscription is good but their prices are too high given the quality. For $1.50 I'd expect a CD-quality song and one that I could burn to CD and not experience lossy music compression. I'd pay $0.50 CDN/song for a 192 Kbps MP3 (higher quality than Apple's format!). The thing is, they'd be capturing *new* entertainment $ that way -- I refuse to buy conventional pop-music because the prices are far too high given the paucity of good quality (and, even, the rarity of good music on pop CDs). PS Did I mention I don't really listen to pop-music anymore (only occasionally on the radio)... the only CDs I buy are from indy bands... don't want to give the a$$holes in the RIAA (& the Cdn equivalent) any more $$$ > I usually transfer files to MY CLIENTS' secure server space using an FTP > application. THAT is the typical way people connect to corporate FTP > servers. The Gnutella, KDX and Hotline networks are not utilized by legit > operations, AFAIK. Hotline is by far the best mass file transfer solution in existence (well, I can't say I've tried any of the Windows stuff... but they mostly require spyware, don't they?), I'd set it up against any platform, any year. Resumable downloads, chat facility, cross-platform compatibility, easy set up of servers, etc. I picked up a few licences for 1.2.3 server & client for a song a few years back and it's the best $40 I ever spent. It's so easy to set up a server, distribute the 1.8.x clients (or, if they're into warez, they'll have it already ;)and transfer your files. Secure! None of the mess of FTP (client incompatibility, platform incompatibility, lost downloads, etc). Don't get me wrong, I love FTP and use it all the time in OS X. However, I would never in my right mind get a computer novice to use FTP if I could have them using Hotline instead (ever tried to get someone an 80 MB file via FTP over a dial-up connection... didn't think so!!!) Once upon a blue moon, FirstClass (in the pre-internet days) was absolutely stunning (for its time). Unfortunately, it seems like the developers of FC have sat on their laurels for the last decade (I bet they still have much of the original code in there). The concepts that the latest FC has are no better than when I last used it in 1992-94. If only web browsers had used FirstClass as a spring board... we'd have some incredibly slick apps by now. FC was fast, stable and a wonderful concept. HTML could've been superimposed quite easily in the early days and the combo of ease of use with TCP/IP & PPP would've opened up a whole new world that we're only seeing glimpses of in Microserf's Winblows XP and maybe, just maybe in OS X Panther. FYI Both FirstClass and Hotline are Canadian companies. Anyway, that's my 55 cents worth (inflation, you know) for the day. -- Mac Canada is sponsored by <http://lowendmac.com/> and... Shop Canadian, visit Mantek Services <http://www.mantek.mb.ca> Low Prices That Will Keep YOU and Your MAC Smiling Educational discounts are now available Support Low End Mac <http://lowendmac.com/lists/support.html> Mac Canada info: <http://lowendmac.com/lists/mac-can.shtml> --> AOL users, remove "mailto:" Send list messages to: <mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]> To unsubscribe, email: <mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]> For digest mode, email: <mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]> Subscription questions: <mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]> Archive: <http://www.mail-archive.com/mac-canada%40mail.maclaunch.com/> Using a Mac? Free email & more at Applelinks! http://www.applelinks.com
