Lee,

I love it when you talk this way.....I have complete techno envy.   

Thanks for the lesson and information.  I will have to see how this goes, I 
have found that the searching does not do as well when the words are white on a 
dark background, guess the OCR can't handle white text.


John


On Jan 2, 2013, at 11:26 AM, Lee Larson wrote:

> On Jan 1, 2013, at 11:37 PM, John Robinson <[email protected]> wrote:
> 
>> You really have me wondering.  On EVERY scan there wasn't a single word 
>> missed, and when I would do a search on even the smallest of print in the 
>> front of the magazine it would find the word every time.  When I would 
>> choose a person or company in Spotlight it would find them, often there 
>> would be six or seven of the now 16 I have now scanned that would have info. 
>> on the question I had ask. 
> 
> We tested by starting with the LaTeX source for several complicated papers in 
> different languages (English, German and French). Then we compiled and 
> printed the results. These were fed through a pretty high-end Xerox scanner. 
> After running OCR, we compared the text layer of the PDF+OCR to the text we 
> started with and worked out the error percentage. After training, we tried it 
> again to see how much improvement was evident.
> 
> All of them were confused by mathematical formulae, but we were mostly 
> interested in the text for searching, so that didn't bother us. None of them 
> consistently scored above 98%. They were somewhat sensitive to fonts, with 
> "Times-like" fonts with serifs seeming to be the best and small sans-serif 
> fonts the worst.
> 
> Since the journal has been using the same fonts for years (CM and Lucida 
> families), training made a lot of difference in figuring out individual 
> glyphs.
> 
> All of these programs use dictionaries to aid in recognizing words. If the 
> program can figure out, say, five of the six letters in a word, then it can 
> make a pretty good guess about the sixth letter using its dictionary. Our 
> text has a lot of technical words that don’t  come in the standard 
> dictionaries bundled with the programs. Training has a great effect here as 
> well.
> 
> 
>> Is there something more I should be looking for?  My needs with 
>> prospectuses, annual reports, Edgar 10k & 2k's.  I will have Barrons (once 
>> they release a PDF ver., can't scan in that large a paper), Investor's 
>> Business Daily, Forbes, Fortune and a few others.  Text will be my main data 
>> but the filings with the SEC will have numbers and tables.  
> 
> If what you're using works, great! But, all of these programs have their own 
> strengths and weaknesses.
> 
>> What am I missing, what do I need that Acrobat may not be giving?
> 
> Maybe nothing. It seems that you're scanning English text with a Times-like 
> font. (Don't really know because I haven't looked at a Forbes in … well … 
> perhaps not this millennium.)
> 
> Another thing to keep in mind is that there aren't really too many different 
> OCR "engines" floating around. There are tons of programs that do OCR, but 
> most of them are using software licensed from Readiris, Omnipage or ABBYY. 
> For example, PDFpen uses Omnipage and many of those low-end programs bundled 
> with scanners use Readiris. You can’t  tell because they slap their own front 
> ends onto the engine.
> 
> There are even a few free engines out there. The only one I've tried is 
> OCRopus. It's pretty fussy, but it does work.
> 
> I usually use Readiris, but I do use PDFpen quite a lot because I can 
> annotate the PDF pretty easily.
> 
> 
> 
> 
> 
> 
> 
> 
> 
> 
> 
> 
> _______________________________________________
> MacGroup mailing list
> [email protected]
> http://www.math.louisville.edu/mailman/listinfo/macgroup

_______________________________________________
MacGroup mailing list
[email protected]
http://www.math.louisville.edu/mailman/listinfo/macgroup

Reply via email to