We better make a strong Maemo council election before discussing deeply the 
MeeGo council. Still, the discussion is worth to prepare current candidates and 
voters.

> actually we have: Nokia --> Quim Gil --> Council (5 Maemo members)

Right.
 
> I would expect now: (Nokia + Intel) --> Community Leader (Quim? he

Actually it's not like this. Even if today it might look that way, I beet the 
picture will be already different by the time a first MeeGo council election 
eventually comes.

MeeGo is a Linux Foundation project that is pushed initially by Nokia and 
Intel, who put a big amount of developers, infrastructure and work together to 
create a free Linux mobile platform. Other organizations and individuals may 
start contributing, get responsibilities, areas of ownership and eventually 
make it to leading positions in working groups and the Technical Steering 
Group. 

All this is a meritocratic structure, and it could benefit from a complementary 
democratic structure. For instance (and I'm improvising here) imagine that the 
chair of the MeeGo community council would sit in the TSG during the "mandate" 
period.

> would be fine :) ) ---> MeeGo Council (2-3 people from Maemo + 2-3
> people from Moblin). In this way we would be sure that both
> communities have a strenght representation in the Council. Of course
> it would be fine too, if in those 2-3 people we would have 1
> @nokia.com and 1 @intel.com....

First why the middlemen like nowadays myself. Once bootstrapped, MeeGo will be 
an open project in a way Maemo has never been. No NDAs will be needed to 
operate in MeeGo and define the roadmaps and strategy. The role of the council 
in this sense needs to be repurposed.

Second, why perpetuating Maemo and Moblin communities. As soon as there is a 
MeeGo architecture, a MeeGo API and MeeGo devices a new community will 
flourish. Now all this feels like a departure and a break, but I'm personally 
so sure that by the end of this year all you N900 users will just feel part of 
the MeeGo community, feeling Maemo as some kind of motherland identity embedded 
and not in conflict with MeeGo. I know well because this is how I feel already 
today, after some time working for this project and a good grasp of how life in 
the MeeGo project is going to be once code, releases and web spaces are 
deployed.

-- 
Quim Gil + N900
open source advocate
Maemo Devices @ Nokia



> -- 
> Andrea Grandi
> email: a.grandi [AT] gmail [DOT] com
> website: http://www.andreagrandi.it
> PGP Key: http://www.andreagrandi.it/pgp_key.asc
> _______________________________________________
> maemo-community mailing list
> [email protected]
> https://lists.maemo.org/mailman/listinfo/maemo-community
> 
_______________________________________________
maemo-community mailing list
[email protected]
https://lists.maemo.org/mailman/listinfo/maemo-community

Reply via email to