On Aug 24, 2011, at 6:33 AM, Barry Leiba wrote: > ** draft-ietf-marf-reporting-discovery-01 > JD posted this version on 27 July, and there have been no comments. > JD, what do you consider the status of this version to be? Do you > think it needs more work, or is it ready to go? Everyone else, please > review this version and post comments, or let us know that you've > reviewed it and you think it's ready.
I could use some help with the ABNF, at which point I think the initial protocol definition work will be complete -- but there still aren't any known implementations, so I wouldn't feel comfortable calling the entire effort finished at that point. My employer has some implementation plans, but we don't have a timeline I can share at present -- and as the largest ARF generator implementation, any changes to the existing system are kind of a big deal. I'd love to see some smaller, more experimentally-minded operators give it a try in the meantime. > ** draft-ietf-marf-redaction-00 > JD posted the first working-group version on 6 April. The only > comment so far is from Murray, who thinks it's ready. We need more > reviews. JD, do you think this version is ready, or do you intend to > post a revision? Others, please review and comment, or let us know > that you think it's done. I think it's ready. > Finally, we have this one pending: > > ** draft-jdfalk-marf-as-00 > JD posted this on 13 May, and there's been little substantive said > about it. It's how we plan to address the charter item that coincides > with MAAWG's feedback loop document (draft-jdfalk-maawg-cfblbcp). Is > this the path the WG wants to take? Shall we adopt this as a WG > document, and proceed with it? Reviews and comments, please. I reposted it as draft-ietf-marf-as-00 (with a few minor changes) earlier today. Looks like there's still some interest in discussing whether to add additional use cases; my opinion is known, but it's a WG document now so I'll bow to consensus. -- J.D. Falk the leading purveyor of industry counter-rhetoric solutions _______________________________________________ marf mailing list [email protected] https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/marf
