Your question was answered honestly and earnestly. The answers were accurate.
You state: >>So, when I asked "who creates the revolution in the means of production, you thought I was asking "is it humans or grasshoppers or chimps or fish or God or Nature "who" create the rev in the means of production. You thought it was a question as to what species or what beings ? That's surely playing dumb. <<< MP: I really am not playing at all and most certainly have no need to play dumb. I am already dumb but what you ask require no real foresight. You ask who creates the revolution in the means of production. At every stage of human development, especially in our early stages of society, individuals come forth whose accumulated knowledge of process logic allows them to innovate and expand the boundary of use of different tools and instruments. See your lawyers games are not worthy of you. Listen to yourself. CB: So, just _all_ human beings create the rev in the means of production, the whole human race ? Or is it a particular sector ? So who created the "Third Wave" , just human beings in the abstract ?<< MP: I most certainly do not speak of all human beings but individuals. Individuals innovate but the character of their actions are more often than not unplanned from the standpoint of a strategic view of the entire process of production. In this sense one can speak of the spontaneous development of the means of production. The question is not posed who created the Third Wave or what I call (and for at least the last five years have called on line), the revolution in the technological regime. The revolution in the technological revolution was most certainly the result of an accumulation of inventions by individuals. Some trace the juncture in the change in the character of technological to the transistor. The transistors replaced the vacuum tube. Some speak of the semiconductor as the juncture in the change of the character of technology. The character of technology means the swift away from movement or motion being driven by electromechanical motion. Your question was answered honestly and straight to the point. See Charles . . . the moment you set yourself up as the authority and arbiter of Marx meaning and refuse to consider an on going collective discussion as broadening your own view, is the moment you shut yourself off from others experiences. Leading questions predicated upon an ideology hostile to mine are no more than simple parlor tricks. Your ideology and mode of thought is that of the petty bourgeois ideologist and more petty than bourgeois. Melvin P. Yea, and also lets answer the question who creates the revolution in the means of production ?<< MP. Pardon Charles . . . . Mr. Lawyer, I answered this question twice already and will answer it again. Human beings create the revolution in the means of production. Production is revolutionized as a result of human ingenuity and I stated this over and over. A human being created say the steam engine and the transistor and the semiconductor and the spinning wheel and the hammer and the hoe. The chariot was created by human beings, as was the sword and slingshot and irrigation canals. ^^^^^ Leninist Lawyer: What a dodge, Wrongline. So, when I asked "who creates the revolution in the means of production, you thought I was asking "is it humans or grasshoppers or chimps or fish or God or Nature "who" create the rev in the means of production. You thought it was a question as to what species or what beings ? That's surely playing dumb. So, just _all_ human beings create the rev in the means of production, the whole human race ? Or is it a particular sector ? So who created the "Third Wave" , just human beings in the abstract ? _______________________________________________ Marxism-Thaxis mailing list [email protected] To change your options or unsubscribe go to: http://lists.econ.utah.edu/mailman/listinfo/marxism-thaxis
