On 11-07-12 10:55 AM, Waldemar Smirnow wrote: > Hi list, > > we had problems to install the Capture Agent under Ubuntu 11.04 and > after I investigated the problem, it turned out that we have a general > issue with the support of Ubuntu 11.04 and all upcoming versions. The > Gstreamer does no longer support V4L. The Epiphan developers adopted > their drivers and the VGA2USB is now a V4L2 device. Because of this they > changed the behavior of the driver, too. Unfortunately this new behavior > is not compatible with the current EpiphanProducer. > > From my point of view we have 3 options now: > 1. Write a second version of the EpiphanProducer that we use in parallel > with the current code, and we check the Gstreamer version at startup to > select the right implementation. The advantage is that Matterhorn is not > dependent on a specific Ubuntu version. The disadvantage is that we have > to maintain and test both versions of the Producer.
Expensive, but probably the best long-term option for interoperability. I'm just not sure how many users are going to want to run the latest and greatest Matterhorn on a mouldy old Ubuntu box. > 2. Support for Ubuntu LTS versions only (on compatible releases). This > would mean we say that we support with the current Matterhorn versions > only Ubuntu 10.04 and compatible releases (9.10 and 10.10 i.e.) and we > would switch to the V4L2 driver model with the Matterhorn released after > Ubuntu 12.04 and than only support the new version. This is probably our best bet. It would mean more extensive testing to determine compatibility however (ie, how far back do we want to test this release?). > 3. Support the current Ubuntu 11.04+ version with the next upcoming > Matterhorn release (probably 1.3) only. We would simply says for each > Matterhorn release which versions of Ubuntu are supported. That would > mean 1.1.x and 1.2.x are supporting Ubuntu < 11.04 and Matterhorn >= 1.3 > will support Ubuntu >= 11.04. When will 1.3 be released? If we're switching to quarterly releases that would push it to September at the earliest, likely December if the 1.3 release takes as long as 1.2. Should we think about switching to straight up Debian for stability purposes? My local institution will be running 1.2 with 10.10 so the decision likely does not affect our deployment, however long term I suspect we will need to run with option 2. G > We here in Osnabrueck are not sure what would be the best way to go. I > guess it will not be too complex to adopt the EpiphanProducer to the new > V4L2 driver, so this is mainly a strategic decision. > > Regards > Waldemar > > _______________________________________________ > Matterhorn mailing list > [email protected] > http://lists.opencastproject.org/mailman/listinfo/matterhorn > > > To unsubscribe please email > [email protected] > _______________________________________________
signature.asc
Description: OpenPGP digital signature
_______________________________________________ Matterhorn mailing list [email protected] http://lists.opencastproject.org/mailman/listinfo/matterhorn To unsubscribe please email [email protected] _______________________________________________
