It's All Decked Out. Give It Somewhere to Go.

By Michael Benson
Sunday, July 13, 2008;

http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2008/07/11/AR2008071102394.html

Consider the International Space Station, that marvel of incremental 
engineering. It has close to 15,000 cubic feet of livable space; 10 
modules, or living and working areas; a Canadian robot arm that can 
repair the station from outside; and the capacity to keep five 
astronauts (including the occasional wealthy rubbernecking space 
tourist) in good health for long periods. It has gleaming, underused 
laboratories; its bathroom is fully repaired; and its exercycle is ready 
for vigorous mandatory workouts.

The only problem with this $156 billion manifestation of human genius -- 
a project as large as a football field that has been called the single 
most expensive thing ever built -- is that it's still going nowhere at a 
very high rate of speed. And as a scientific research platform, it still 
has virtually no purpose and is accomplishing nothing.

I try not to write this cavalierly. But if the station's goal is to 
conduct yet more research into the effects of zero gravity on human 
beings, well, there's more than enough of that already salted away in 
Russian archives, based on the many years of weightlessness that 
cosmonauts heroically logged in a series of space stations throughout 
the 1970s, '80s and '90s. By now, ISS crews have also spent serious time 
in zero gravity. We know exactly what weightlessness does and how to 
counter some of its atrophying effects. (Cue shot of exercycle.)

And if the station's purpose is to act as a "stepping stone" to places 
beyond -- well, that metaphor, most recently used by NASA Administrator 
Michael Griffin is pure propaganda. As any student of celestial 
mechanics can tell you, if you want to go somewhere in space, the best 
policy is to go directly there and not stop along the way, because 
stopping is a waste of precious fuel, time and treasure. Which is a 
pretty good description of the ISS, parked as it is in constant low 
Earth orbit.

This is no doubt why, after the horrifying disintegration of the space 
shuttle Columbia in 2003, the Bush administration belatedly recognized 
that, if we're going to spend all that money on manned spaceflight, we 
should justify the risks by actually sending our astronauts somewhere. 
So NASA is now developing a new generation of rockets and manned 
spacecraft. By 2020, the Constellation program is supposed to take 
astronauts beyond low Earth orbit for the first time since Apollo 17 
returned from the moon in 1972. Yes, that'll be almost 50 years. Where 
will they go? To the moon -- the only place humans have already visited.

Which leads us right back to the expensively orbiting ISS. It hasn't a 
fig-leaf's role left. The moon is the new "stepping stone," with Mars 
bruited as a next destination. Although NASA officials will never quite 
say so, their current attitude seems to be that the station is 
essentially a high-maintenance distraction, even a mistake. Their plan 
is to finish assembling the thing ASAP and hand the keys over to the 
Russians, Canadians, Europeans and Japanese, with minimal continuing 
U.S. involvement. This should happen by the shuttle's mandatory 
retirement in 2010. Meanwhile, we're still writing a lot of 
high-denomination checks and preparing the two remaining shuttles for 
risky flights to finish something we then plan to be largely rid of. 
This seems absurd. I have an alternative proposal:

Send the ISS somewhere.

The ISS, you see, is already an interplanetary spacecraft -- at least 
potentially. It's missing a drive system and a steerage module, but 
those are technicalities. Although it's ungainly in appearance, it's 
designed to be boosted periodically to a higher altitude by a shuttle, a 
Russian Soyuz or one of the upcoming new Constellation program Orion 
spacecraft. It could fairly easily be retrofitted for operations beyond 
low-Earth orbit. In principle, we could fly it almost anywhere within 
the inner solar system -- to any place where it could still receive 
enough solar power to keep all its systems running.

It's easy to predict what skeptics both inside and outside NASA will say 
to this idea. They'll point out that the new Constellation program is 
already supposed to have at least the beginnings of interplanetary 
ability. They'll say that the ISS needs to be resupplied too frequently 
for long missions. They'll worry about the amount of propellant needed 
to push the ISS's 1,040,000 pounds anywhere -- not to mention bringing 
them all back.

There are good answers to all these objections. We'll still need the new 
Constellation Ares boosters and Orion capsules -- fortuitously, they can 
easily be adapted to a scenario in which the ISS becomes the living- 
area and lab core of an interplanetary spacecraft. The Ares V heavy-lift 
booster could easily send aloft the additional supplies and storage and 
drive modules necessary to make the ISS truly deep-space-worthy.

The Orion crew exploration module is designed to be ISS-compatible. It 
could serve as a guidance system and also use its own rocket engine to 
help boost and orient the interplanetary ISS. After remaining dormant 
for much of the one-year journey to, say, Mars, it could then be 
available to conduct independent operations while the ISS core orbited 
the Red Planet, or to investigate an asteroid near Earth, for instance.

But, the skeptics will say, the new Orion capsule's engines wouldn't be 
nearly enough; a spacecraft as large as the ISS would need its own drive 
system. Here, too, we're in surprisingly good shape. The ISS is already 
in space; the amount of thrust it needs to go farther is a lot less than 
you might think. Moreover, a drive system doesn't have to be based on 
chemical rockets. Over the past two decades, both the U.S. and Japanese 
programs have conducted highly successful tests in space of ion-drive 
systems. Unlike the necessarily impatient rockets we use to escape 
Earth's gravity and reach orbit, these long-duration, low-thrust engines 
produce the kind of methodical acceleration (and deceleration) 
appropriate for travel once a spacecraft is already floating in zero 
gravity. They would be a perfect way to send the ISS on its way and 
bring it back to Earth again.

This leaves a lander. A lunar lander substantially larger than the 
spidery Apollo-era LEMs is currently on the drawing board. It's not 
nearly as far along in development as the Ares booster and Orion 
spacecraft components of the Constellation program -- which is a good 
thing. While I question the need to return to the moon in the first 
place, I wouldn't exclude it as a possible destination, so I think we 
should modify the lander's design to make it capable of touching down on 
either the moon or Mars and then returning to the ISS with samples for 
study in its laboratories. Such landers could also investigate the 
moon's poles, where we think water may be present, or one of the 
near-Earth asteroids -- which may have raw materials suitable for use by 
future generations of space explorers.

But, our skeptics will sputter, this will all cost far more money than 
the Constellation program. Who'll pay for it?

Actually, it will in effect save all the money we've already spent on 
the ISS. And the station is already an international project, with 
substantial financial and technological input from the Russians, 
Canadians, Europeans and Japanese. In recent years, the Chinese, who 
have developed their own human spaceflight capabilities, have made 
repeated overtures to NASA, hoping to be let in on the ISS project. 
They've been unceremoniously rebuffed by the Bush administration, but a 
new administration may be more welcoming. An interplanetary ISS -- the 
acronym now standing for International Space Ship -- would be a truly 
international endeavor, with expenses shared among all participating 
nations.

How likely is any of this to happen? Not very. A lot depends on the 
flexibility of a NASA that hasn't always been particularly welcoming to 
outside ideas. On the other hand, the agency also collaborates with 
outsiders all the time. So it's not impossible. The reason the ISS went 
from being a purely American, Reagan-era project ("Space Station 
Freedom") to one including the Russians and many other nations was a 
political decision by the Clinton administration. A similar political 
vision will be necessary here.

All the billions already spent on the space station would pay off -- 
spectacularly -- if this product of human ingenuity actually went 
somewhere and did something. But it would also serve as a compelling 
demonstration that we're one species, living on one planet, and that 
we're as capable of cooperating peacefully as we are at competing 
militaristically. Let's begin the process of turning the ISS from an 
Earth-orbiting caterpillar into an interplanetary butterfly.

-- 

Gregory S. Williams
gregwilliams(at)knology.net
k4hsm(at)knology.net

http://www.etskywarn.net
http://www.twiar.org
http://www.icebearnation.com


*******************************
* POST TO [EMAIL PROTECTED] *
*******************************

Medianews mailing list
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
http://lists.etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews

Reply via email to