Google, Yahoo Defend Ad-Sharing Deal
Executives from Internet-search giants appear at Senate Judiciary 
Committee Antitrust Subcommittee hearing.
By John Eggerton -- Broadcasting & Cable, 7/15/2008 12:13:00 PM

http://www.broadcastingcable.com/article/CA6578868.html

Google and Yahoo defended their ad-sharing deal at a Senate Judiciary 
Committee Antitrust Subcommittee hearing in Washington, D.C., Tuesday, 
with some sparks flying as Microsoft dueled with the two companies over 
whether the deal was an anticompetitive consolidation of the search 
business that Microsoft is trying to get a bigger piece of.

The deal, which has been under attack by Microsoft as anticompetitive, 
would instead benefit consumers, advertisers and, admittedly, Google and 
Yahoo, the companies told legislators, while continuing to protect 
surfers’ online privacy.

Michael Callahan, general counsel for Yahoo, and David Drummond, chief 
legal officer for Yahoo, said they would continue to compete vigorously 
for online search. Callahan said the deal is not a merger, and it will 
not give Google control over 90% of online search -- Google currently 
has about 70%, Yahoo about 20%-25%. Callahan added that Yahoo would try 
to grow that.

Chairman Sen. Herb Kohl (D-Wis.) said critics of the deal were 
characterizing it as Google paying for Yahoo not to compete as 
vigorously. Callahan said this was not the case and his company was not 
ceding any of its own algorithmic-search business.

Brad Smith, general counsel of Microsoft, jumped in to say that Yahoo 
chief executive Jerry Yang said at a June 8 meeting with Microsoft that 
the deal would mean that there were currently two poles in search -- 
Google on one side and Microsoft and Yahoo on the other. With the deal, 
Yang said, Yahoo would join Google's pole.

Kohl began the hearing by posting the question of whether the deal 
reduced Yahoo to nothing more than the newest satellite in the Google 
orbit. Smith said the answer was obviously yes.

Callahan, who said he was also at that June 8 meeting, would not 
characterize Yang's comments but asserted that Yahoo would continue to 
compete aggressively for search. Kohl said that appeared to contradict 
the company's own top executive.

When pressed, Callahan said he didn't agree with Smith's 
characterization of Yang's comment and didn't recall the "one-pole" 
comment. Sen. Arlen Specter (R-Pa.) reminded him that he was under oath 
and said the committee might need another hearing to follow up on the issue.

Drummond seconded Callahan's defense of the deal as a win-win for 
consumers, advertisers and his company. He said the nonexclusive deal 
would create new efficiencies that will allow advertisers to better 
target their messages, pointing to ad agencies like Publicis and 
Digitas, which support the deal.

Both Callahan and Drummond said the companies would not fix prices and 
that more money would not come from raising prices per ad, but from more 
people clicking on more ads.

Matthew Crowley, chief marketing officer of AT&T's Yellowpages.com, took 
issue with the rosy picture, saying that the deal would give Yahoo 
reason not to compete and that he would wind up paying higher rates for 
less inventory on Yahoo.

Specter, former chairman of the committee, said Crowley's arguments were 
"impressive," and that it was hard to accept the argument that control 
of 90% of the market would not be anti-competitive.

Callahan countered that the 90% figure would only be relevant if Yahoo 
were getting out of the search business, which it is not.

Microsoft, a latecomer to the search business, made a bid to buy Yahoo. 
Yahoo investor Carl Icahn supports the deal and is waging a proxy fight 
for control of the board.

The House Judiciary Committee is scheduled to hear from some of the same 
witnesses Tuesday afternoon at its own hearing on online advertising and 
the deal.
*******************************
* POST TO [EMAIL PROTECTED] *
*******************************

Medianews mailing list
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
http://lists.etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews

Reply via email to