Study: shrinking newsrooms hurting papers' quality

Jul 21, 2008  12:20 AM (ET)

By JEREMY HERRON
Associated Press

http://apnews.myway.com//article/20080721/D9220ULG0.html


NEW YORK (AP) - The many and deepening cuts at newspapers across the 
country are starting to take a toll on their content, according to a study 
being released Monday.

The challenge newspapers must meet immediately is to find more revenue on 
the Internet, according to the Project for Excellence in Journalism's 
study, called "The Changing Newsroom: What is Being Gained and What is 
Being Lost in America's Daily Newspapers."

Newspaper managers need to "find a way to monetize the rapid growth of Web 
readership before newsroom staff cuts so weaken newspapers that their 
competitive advantage disappears."

Stories are shorter overall, the study found, and staff coverage tends to 
focus on local and community news.

"America's newspapers are narrowing their reach and their ambitions and 
becoming niche reads," the study said.

Even when foreign and national news makes it into the papers, it is being 
relegated to less prominent pages.

"To make the front page, it has to be a significant development or a story 
that we can see through Florida eyes," said Sharon Rosenhause, managing 
editor of the Fort Lauderdale-based South Florida Sun-Sentinel and a 
longtime newspaper executive.

The reasons for the newsroom cutbacks are well known: Newsprint costs have 
jumped, and advertising and circulation revenue have quickened their 
descent this year as advertisers follow readers online. Newspaper Web sites 
capture only a small fraction of the revenue lost as they sell fewer print 
ads, which fetch more money.

"The seams and threads are beginning to show in U.S. journalism even though 
newspapers are by far the greatest source of news," Lou Ureneck, chairman 
of the journalism department at Boston University, said Friday.

The PEJ study surveyed senior newsroom executives at more than 250 
newspapers and interviewed editors at papers in 15 cities to document the 
way these cuts have affected newsrooms and the quality of their product.

The results show that papers carry fewer stories on foreign and national 
news and devote less space to business, science and arts reporting, and 
many have reduced the crossword puzzle and eliminated television and stock 
listings.

Many editors said they must ask reporters to cover more beats, reducing 
their ability to produce authoritative stories. Others said, in what may 
create a vicious circle, that staff cutbacks reduce their ability to shape 
coverage to fit their communities' needs, and Ureneck said that coverage is 
shrinking.

"This is a strategic move not driven by lack of demand but (by) a revenue 
model that is broken," Ureneck said.

Still, 56 percent of the editors surveyed said their news product is better 
than it was three years ago because coverage is more targeted.

"There's an improvement in enterprise, in investigations and in the 
coverage of several core beats," the study quoted an unnamed editor of a 
large metropolitan daily talking about his staff's coverage, not the makeup 
of the paper overall.

Local news is "very essential" to their product, according to 97 percent of 
editors surveyed, and they said that's where they're putting a larger share 
of their shrinking resources.

"They are giving a greater piece of a smaller pie to local news," Ureneck 
said. That makes sense because where they can "develop the most expertise 
and strongest bond with readers is covering the local community."

The newsroom is much younger than three years ago, and reporters are more 
technology savvy and able to meet the demands of print and online stories, 
according to the study.

Editors once leery of producing content for the Web are increasingly 
embracing its potential to diversify readership and improve journalism, 
even if it sometimes saps print resources.

"Editors feel torn between the advantages the Web offers and the energy it 
consumes to produce material often of limited or even questionable value," 
the study said.

The Web speeds delivery of news, allows interaction with readers and opens 
nearly infinite space for news.

"The downside is that is has eroded the advertising base in print 
publications, and that is by far the main source of revenue to pay for 
large news staffs," Ureneck said.

Editors see the ability to track readership of any specific story online as 
an advantage for improving content. It provides an "indisputable link 
between strong editorial content and the kind of higher readership that 
attracts advertisers," the study said.

The editors, 97 percent of whom said they are active in trying to develop 
new revenue streams, can then convince the advertising sales staff to 
become more targeted in selling to the Web.

Many said, though, that they were uncertain improved editorial content 
would ensure a bright future - especially since most organizations failed 
to anticipate the changes that have wracked newsrooms in recent years.

Only 5 percent of the editors surveyed said they were confident they could 
predict what the newsroom would look like in five years.

"I feel I'm being catapulted into another world, a world I don't really 
understand," Virigian-Pilot editor Dennis Finley told PEJ. "Things are 
happening at the speed of light."

The results of the survey, conducted online by Princeton Survey Research 
Associates International between Jan. 29 and Feb. 29, include responses 
from over 50 percent of U.S. papers with 100,000 or more in circulation and 
more than 30 percent of papers with 50,000 to 100,000 in circulation.


================================
George Antunes, Political Science Dept
University of Houston; Houston, TX 77204
Voice: 713-743-3923  Fax: 713-743-3927
antunes at uh dot edu

*******************************
* POST TO [EMAIL PROTECTED] *
*******************************

Medianews mailing list
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
http://lists.etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews

Reply via email to