Purdue panel finds misconduct by fusion scientist

Jul 18, 2008  5:15 PM (ET)

By DEANNA MARTIN
Associated Press

http://apnews.myway.com//article/20080718/D920GHNO6.html


INDIANAPOLIS (AP) - A Purdue University panel has found two instances of 
misconduct by a researcher who claims he produced nuclear fusion in 
tabletop experiments.

Rusi Taleyarkhan made headlines in 2002 when he published a paper in the 
journal Science claiming that he had produced nuclear fusion by making tiny 
bubbles collapse in a liquid. The new report found misconduct in subsequent 
papers.

The Purdue committee, which includes representatives from other schools, 
said that in a follow-up paper published in 2006 in Physical Review 
Letters, Taleyarkhan falsely claimed that his 2002 work had been confirmed 
independently. In fact, Taleyarkhan was extensively involved in the work he 
claimed was done independently of him, the committee found.

The panel also found that in a pair of 2005 papers, Taleyarkhan added 
another person as an author even though that researcher did not 
substantially contribute.

The committee did not investigate the 2002 paper itself, in which 
Taleyarkhan and colleagues reported signs of nuclear fusion in a small 
laboratory device. Scientists have long sought a simple way to produce 
fusion in hopes of harnessing it as an energy source.

The original paper six years ago was met with widespread skepticism. In an 
unusual move, Science published a companion piece from two researchers at 
Oak Ridge National Laboratory in Tennessee - where Taleyarkhan worked at 
the time - that said they could not reproduce the result.

Other scientists, including some at Purdue, where Taleyarkhan now works, 
have tried without success to independently reproduce his results.

A spokeswoman for Science said Friday that the journal "will consider the 
implications" of the new report's findings for the 2002 paper.

In a statement released Friday by his attorney, Taleyarkhan said he will 
take the time to review his options.

Taleyarkhan has contended that other scientists have replicated his work 
and has accused his critics of conflict of interest, jealousy and other 
motives. He filed a defamation lawsuit this year accusing two Purdue 
professors of trying to destroy him and his reputation.

The Purdue committee submitted its findings in April to the Office of Naval 
Research, which funded some of Taleyarkhan's research. Purdue said Friday 
the naval office accepted the report, calling it prompt, thorough and 
objective.

"From small beginnings there developed a tangled web of wishful thinking, 
scientific misjudgment, institutional lapses and human failings," the 
committee wrote. "Each strand could have been resolved separately, but 
knitting them together produced a crisis."

University policy includes a 30-day appeal process for Taleyarkhan. Purdue 
said it will not comment on the report's content during that period, but 
David J. Williams, who leads the Purdue University Senate's Faculty Affairs 
Committee, said the document is an unflinching look at the case.

"Issues of research integrity are of the utmost importance to the 
university," Williams said.

Any decision on sanctions by the university would come after the appeals 
process is over.

Gene Sprouse, editor-in-chief of the American Physical Society, which 
publishes Physical Review Letters, said the society would also take no 
action before the appeal period has expired.

---

On the Web:

The panel's full report: http://tinyurl.com/5zxky6

Office of Naval Research letter: http://tinyurl.com/5o7hp4



================================
George Antunes, Political Science Dept
University of Houston; Houston, TX 77204
Voice: 713-743-3923  Fax: 713-743-3927
antunes at uh dot edu

*******************************
* POST TO [EMAIL PROTECTED] *
*******************************

Medianews mailing list
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
http://lists.etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews

Reply via email to