September 26, 2008 5:05 PM PDT

Google reveals wireless hopes in a patent

By Marguerite Reardon
News.com

http://news.cnet.com/8301-1035_3-10052709-94.html?tag=newsEditorsPicksArea.0


Google's vision of tomorrow's wireless network is in stark contrast to how 
wireless operators do business today, setting the two sides on a possible 
collision course.

Earlier this week, the search giant filed a patent application with the 
U.S. Patent Office describing its vision of an open wireless network where 
smartphones aren't tied to any single cell phone network. In Google's open 
wireless world, phones and other wireless devices would search for the 
strongest, fastest connection at the most competitive price. Essentially, 
wireless operators' networks would be reduced to "dumb pipes."

The idea is that depending on where a wireless user is at any given time, 
he could be on any number of networks. For example, if coverage is better 
from Verizon Wireless at home, a subscriber might connect to that network 
to make phone calls. But he might use AT&T while at work, where the signal 
is stronger. Price would also be a factor, and operators would constantly 
be vying in a sort of auction to provide the most competitive pricing for 
the call.

Meanwhile, users could also access other free or low-cost networks. So if, 
for example, someone wanted to surf the Web from their phone they could 
connect via a Wi-Fi or WiMax network. Or people may even be able to connect 
to a network that uses yet-to-be available "white space" spectrum.

This notion of a device connecting to any network is quite different from 
how the wireless industry operates today. When people buy cell phones 
today, they're essentially locked to one provider. A particular provider 
may have roaming agreements with other cell phone operators, but customers 
have a contract and billing relationship with one cell phone operator. And 
if they decide to switch carriers, they usually have to pay a penalty for 
breaking a contract, and they must purchase a phone that will work on the 
new network.

Of course, consumers don't have the same issues in the broadband market, 
where people can connect to any broadband network using any computer, 
whether it be a Wi-Fi, cable or DSL connection.

Carriers are beginning to offer consumers some alternatives. Apple's 
iPhone, which is sold exclusively in the U.S. on AT&T's network, also has 
Wi-Fi. And users regularly choose to surf the Net on Wi-Fi connections. 
T-Mobile has a service that allows subscribers with Wi-Fi enabled phones to 
switch between the T-Mobile cellular network and a home Wi-Fi connection.

Verizon Wireless also recently announced it would not require contracts in 
exchange for consumers paying full retail price for devices. And all four 
of the major mobile carriers in the U.S. have begun pro-rating contracts so 
that the penalty for leaving a service before the contract expires 
decreases over time.


Playing by the rules

But wireless operators have stopped short of offering truly open networks 
that would allow consumers to bring any device onto their networks. For 
instance, Verizon Wireless' Open Network Initiative announced last year 
isn't really open. The company isn't allowing any device to connect to its 
network. It's simply speeding up the certification process.

Executives at these companies argue that they need to certify devices to 
ensure service quality. Recently, T-Mobile CEO Robert Dotson told an 
audience at the CTIA tradeshow in San Francisco that "even though on the 
outside (an open device network) looks enticing, there still needs to be a 
minimum level of control to safeguard security and privacy."

For the meantime, it looks like Google is being forced to play by these 
carrier rules. Earlier this week, T-Mobile USA launched the G1, the first 
smartphone to use Google's Android operating system. The phone is set to go 
on sale in October, but it will be locked to T-Mobile's network.

That said, Google has high hopes for changing the market, whether carriers 
like it or not. It has been lobbying the Federal Communications Commission 
and Congress for well over a year to adopt policies that reflect its vision 
of an open network. Last year it convinced the FCC to agree to add an open 
network provision in the rules for the 700MHz spectrum auction. And then it 
helped ensure the provision would take effect by bidding on the spectrum so 
that it reached a predetermined threshold. It's also been pushing the FCC 
to open up the so-called white spaces between TV channels for unlicensed use.

Google has also been investing in alternative wireless technology and 
networks. It's investing $500 million in the new Sprint/ClearwireWiMax 
joint venture, which is trying to build a nationwide network using WiMax. 
The company has dabbled in citywide Wi-Fi. It's already attempted to buy 
wireless spectrum. And it's been investing in its own fiber infrastructure 
as well in the form of undersea cable deployments, which could eventually 
be used to create high-speed backhaul networks.

Still, there are several challenges to making Google's open network a 
reality. For one, device manufacturers would have to cram in more radios 
into devices to handle all the potential wireless networks that consumers 
might encounter. While this is not impossible, it does complicate device 
design and could drive costs up and battery life down. Also, designing 
devices to seamlessly switch among all those networks is not a trivial 
task. In fact, users have complained about the iPhone 3G's ability to 
switch between 2.5G and 3G networks.

What's more, a real-time wireless auction system would have to be in place 
to manage network usage in Google's ideal wireless world. This actually 
could be an opportunity for Google, according to a blog on Wired News. The 
patent explicitly outlines "a transparent auction marketplace with wireless 
providers bidding in real time to provide the communication services to 
users." And the blog notes that Google may be well-suited to establish such 
a marketplace because of its experience with AdWords and AdSense.

One thing is certain, Google has a long way to go before its vision is 
realized. But as wireless networks handle more data and become more 
Internet-enabled, it's only a matter of time before openness is forced onto 
carriers whether they like it or not.


================================
George Antunes, Political Science Dept
University of Houston; Houston, TX 77204
Voice: 713-743-3923  Fax: 713-743-3927
antunes at uh dot edu

*******************************
* POST TO [EMAIL PROTECTED] *
*******************************

Medianews mailing list
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
http://lists.etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews

Reply via email to