I’ve watched the economy for 30 years. Now I’m truly scared

Will Hutton
London Observer
Monday, Sept 29, 2008

http://www.prisonplanet.com/ive-watched-the-economy-for-30-years-now-im-truly-scared.html

If more people understood what has happened in the British and American 
banking system, the financial crisis would only be containable by the 
immediate partial nationalisation of every bank in Britain and America. 
There was not a run on the banks by depositors queuing in the streets to 
withdraw their savings. Rather, it was an escalating and terrifying run 
on the banks in effect by themselves, which, if it spread to millions of 
small savers, would reproduce the events of 1929.

In Britain, the money markets that the banks organise between themselves 
completely froze. Such was the break down in trust and sense of panic 
that some of the most familiar names in British high street banking 
would not lend to each other at all or, at best, just overnight. 
Instead, the Bank of England had to supply tens of billions to banks who 
found the normal sources of funds blocked.

I have been writing on the financial markets for nearly 30 years. I have 
known the system was becoming increasingly fragile, but for all the 
ferocity of my criticisms, I never expected the scale of today’s events. 
Or that I would begin to wonder whether my own bank would survive 
without nationalisation. The negotiations in Washington over this 
weekend to finalise the $700bn Paulson financial bail-out plan, and the 
expected vote on Sunday, are all that stands between the Anglo-American 
banking system and a first-order disaster. The scheme had better work.

This is not the end of capitalism, as some wildly claim; there is no 
intellectual, social or political challenge to a market system based on 
respect for private property rights, even by the Chinese Communist 
party. Rather, it is a crisis of a particular capitalism that has set 
aside respect for trust, integrity and fairness as fuddy-duddy obstacles 
to ‘wealth generation’. What we are relearning is that without trust and 
fairness, capitalism risks its own sustainability, even while it 
unleashes forces that undermine those self-same values. London’s money 
markets froze because of a trust collapse; banks simply don’t believe 
each other when they say their businesses are sound and will not default 
on their obligations. Trust matters.

And although some conservatives in Britain and America continue to make 
the ideological case against any government action as a response to the 
recent turmoil - governments necessarily do everything worse than the 
market - they have no alternative proposal about how to restore trust 
once it has gone. Trust is a reciprocal relationship, dependent upon a 
desire to be considered decent and honourable. Even in the dog-eat-dog 
financial markets, trust and integrity are matters of self-interest. 
However amoral you may be, it is in your interest to care about your 
reputation, because if you behave badly you will not do business with me 
- or others - on favourable terms again.

But the scale of the personal rewards now available in London and Wall 
Street - £15m-£20m at the top is the norm - along with the greed-is-good 
doctrine associated with extreme laissez-faire economics, has trashed 
the need for individuals to worry about integrity. They don’t need to be 
concerned about their reputations; they just need one deal or one year 
at the top and they need never work again. The incentive structure has 
so departed from one of the principal norms of fairness - 
proportionality between value added and reward - that it has eviscerated 
trust relationships and integrity.

Everybody tries to ‘game’ the system on their route to vast personal 
fortunes - whether short-selling, packaging up dud mortgages as prime 
mortgages or telling lies about their financial viability - and the 
result is that the system is getting wise. The best course today in any 
financial transaction is to presume zero integrity. Credit is drying up 
and with it the very lifeblood of the economy.

Worse, now that the system is in trouble, financiers are turning to 
taxpayers in the US and Britain for help without understanding the other 
key principal of fairness - that we will consider helping those who for 
no fault of their own get into trouble, but not those who freely created 
their own bad circumstances.
*******************************
* POST TO [EMAIL PROTECTED] *
*******************************

Medianews mailing list
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
http://lists.etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews

Reply via email to