Cox Responds to DMCA 'Three Strikes' Report
Says they've only terminated 'one-tenth of 1% of all users'

http://www.dslreports.com/shownews/Cox-Responds-to-DMCA-Three-Strikes-Report-98149

Yesterday, we directed your attention to a report that stated Cox is 
using a "three strikes and you're out" policy to disconnect users who 
receive multiple DMCA copyright warnings. Cox saw the blogging buzz 
about their policy, and wanted a chance to comment on the public 
reaction. "I came across your blog post about Cox’s DMCA policies and 
I’d like to share some additional information with you to help shed some 
light on how we handle DMCA complaints," says Cox public relations 
official David Deliman.

Deliman says that to characterize this as a "three strikes and you’re 
out" policy "doesn’t reflect the true process" because there's ample 
warning. As you might expect, Deliman portrays the policy more as a 
public service effort on Cox's part, saying that in many cases (he 
raises the example of an inattentive parent), "the customer doesn't even 
know that the illegal material is on their computer."

"This notification is the most helpful thing we can do for the 
customer," he says. "If they don’t realize the RIAA or another 
organization has identified them as possibly infringing on their 
copyrights, they might get sued instead," he claims.

Cox also insists that the program impacts only a tiny fraction of the 
Cox customer base. The cable company has sent hundreds of thousands of 
warnings to customers, but have only had to terminate the accounts of 
less than one-tenth of 1% of all users. That's because if the initial 
e-mail notification doesn't work, customers almost always respond when 
they're placed in a "walled garden."

Cox was among the first ISPs to use malware walled gardens to cordon 
infected users off from the Internet at large until they've cleaned 
their PC. But by utilizing the same method at the behest of the 
entertainment industry to tackle pirates (given the DMCA only requires 
user notification) Cox is voluntarily doing more than necessary while 
adding to their own support costs. Why? Scaring teenage kids probably 
helps trim P2P traffic.

This was an anti-congestion tactic a Comcast insider told me the 
nation's largest cable company was also considering, though Comcast 
public relations denied any such plans when asked over the phone. The 
entertainment industry has been pushing ISPs to become piracy police 
(most recently arguing P2P is as bad as spam and viruses), and 
apparently some cable operators see this as a perfect opportunity to 
ease congestion on their networks.

Still, Deliman insists that Cox doesn't tread lightly into that 
DMCA-enforcing night. "Please know that we work with customers 
extensively to help educate them about copyright laws and action is not 
taken lightly," he says. "In no way do we see ourselves as Internet 
police, and we make every effort to keep our customers online."

While that's well and good, it still doesn't explain why Cox has to 
mislead consumers. Their warning to customers insists that under the 
DMCA, "we have the responsibility to temporarily disable your Internet 
access." Again, the DMCA only requires that ISPs forward DMCA warnings 
on to customers -- Cox's decision to inundate their support staff with 
the task of P2P policing is voluntary.
*******************************
* POST TO [EMAIL PROTECTED] *
*******************************

Medianews mailing list
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
http://lists.etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews

Reply via email to