OCTOBER 3, 2008

Music Royalties to Hold Steady

By ETHAN SMITH
Wall Street Journal

http://online.wsj.com/article/SB122298009064099449.html


A panel of federal judges opted not to change a century-old method for 
calculating royalties on music sales, despite calls by some in the 
industry to overhaul the system in order to account for the sweeping 
changes ushered in by the digital distribution.

However, the panel did for the first time issue a royalty rate for ring 
tones.

Under the new guidelines issued Thursday by the three-judge Copyright 
Royalty Board for the so-called compulsory rate for mechanical 
royalties, record companies are to continue paying 9.1 cents a song 
sold, whether it is a digital download or on a compact disc. Music 
publishers, represented by the National Music Publishers Association, 
had sought a higher rate for downloads -- 15 cents a sale -- a proposal 
opposed by Apple Inc. and the operators of other online music stores.

In a stark illustration of how the value of music has flat-lined in 
recent years, the rate on CD and download sales isn't set to rise at all 
for the next five years, remaining at the same level it has been at 
since 2006. That will be the first time in 30 years that the compulsory 
rate has remained flat for such a long period. The rate was fixed at two 
cents a song sold from 1900 until 1977 and has increased to its current 
level gradually every two or three years since.

Some technology companies and record labels had sought to change the way 
they compensate publishers for song downloads, from the current 
so-called penny rate to a percentage of revenue. They had argued that 
calculating royalties that way could make room for greater flexibility 
in developing new business models. In an interview, NMPA Chief Executive 
David Israelite called that portion of the decision "a major victory." 
He added: "Songs have intrinsic value, and therefore the penny rate is 
the most appropriate way for us to be compensated."

Mitch Bainwol, CEO of the trade group for record labels, the Recording 
Industry Association of America, said in a prepared statement, "No party 
got everything it wanted, yet at the end of the day, the certainty 
provided by this ruling is beneficial."

A spokesman for the Copyright Royalty Board declined to comment because 
he said the guidelines weren't supposed to be made public until next 
week. Apple spokesman Tom Neumayr Thursday said: "We're pleased with the 
CRB's decision to keep royalty rates stable." An executive at Apple last 
year told the royalty board that the company might shut down its iTunes 
Store if rates increased as drastically as music publishers wanted, 
though the company never discussed such a possibility with record companies.

The board set a rate of 24 cents for ring tones -- short snippets of 
songs that are sold as ringers for cellphones, often for $2 or $3. The 
new rate is more than either the music publishers or the record labels 
had proposed, according to people familiar with the matter. Prices and 
sales of ringtones have been dropping recently. Until now, without 
government-issued guidelines, record labels, publishers and cellphone 
carriers have been left to negotiate royalties among themselves for 
ringtones.

Jonathan Potter, executive director of the Digital Media Association, 
which represents online services like Apple's iTunes Store and Yahoo 
Inc., said keeping the rate unchanged would "help digital services and 
retailers continue to innovate and grow."

*******************************
* POST TO [EMAIL PROTECTED] *
*******************************

Medianews mailing list
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
http://lists.etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews

Reply via email to