Supremes Mull Whether Bad Databases Make for Illegal Searches

By Ryan Singel
Wired News

October 04, 2008 | 5:26:37 PM

http://blog.wired.com/27bstroke6/2008/10/supremes-mull-w.html


If a false entry in a database leads to a unconstitutional police search 
that reveals illegal drugs, does the government get to hold it against you?

That's the question the Supreme Court will tackle on Tuesday in a case 
civil liberties groups such as the Electronic Privacy Information Center 
argue will have broad implications in a world where we are constantly 
being evaluated against databases and watch lists that are riddled with 
frustratingly persistent errors.

"In these interlinked databases, one error can spread like a disease, 
infecting every system it touches and condemning the individual to whom 
this error refers to suffer substantial delay, harassment, and improper 
arrest," EPIC director Marc Rotenberg argued in a friend of the court 
brief .

Not surprisingly, the government disagrees.

"Police officers in the field must be allowed to rely on information 
they receive from others when it is reasonable to do so," the Justice 
Department wrote in its brief (.pdf), arguing that throwing out the 
evidence won't make errors less likely.

At issue is the case of Bennie Herring, an Alabama man who drove to the 
police station in July 2004 to try to retrieve items from an impounded 
pickup truck. A Coffee County cop recognized him, asked the clerk to 
check the database for outstanding warrant.

None was found, so the investigator asked the clerk to call the 
neighboring Dale county clerk to see if it had a warrant for Herring.

The Dale county clerk found a warrant for Herring in their database, so 
the Coffee County cops set out after Herring after asking the other 
county to fax the warrant over.

Herring was soon pulled over and the police found meth in his pocket and 
a pistol under the truck's seat.

But in the meantime, the Dale county clerk found that there was no 
warrant for Herring and the entry should have been removed five months 
previous.

In court, Herring moved to have the evidence thrown out, but instead was 
sentenced to 27 months for being a convicted felon in possession of a 
firearm.

No one – not even the government - disputes that the search was 
unconstitutional.

But the courts – including the 11th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals – 
aren't convinced that throwing out evidence from a 
tainted-database-initiated search will make the system better.

"Hoping to gain a beneficial deterrent effect on Dale County personnel 
by excluding evidence in a case brought by Coffee County officers would 
be like telling a student that if he skips school one of his classmates 
will be punished," Judge Edward Carnes wrote in a 2007 opinion.

"The student may not exactly relish the prospect of causing another to 
suffer, but human nature being what it is, he is unlikely to fear that 
prospect as much as he would his own suffering. "

Instead Carnes suggests victims of bad government databases should find 
their justice by filing a civil suit against the responsible parties.

Civil liberties groups say such suits are unlikely to succeed and that 
the Constitution should protect people from watch lists and databases 
relied on more and more by the government, even as it denies 
responsibility for keeping them accurate.

The case is Herring vs. US 07-513.

*******************************
* POST TO [EMAIL PROTECTED] *
*******************************

Medianews mailing list
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
http://lists.etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews

Reply via email to