October 6, 2008

The Long Countdown
One Way Up: U.S. Space Plan Relies on Russia

By JOHN SCHWARTZ
NY Times

http://www.nytimes.com/2008/10/06/science/space/06gap.html?hp=&pagewanted=print


STAR CITY, Russia — This place was once no place, a secret military base 
northeast of Moscow that did not show up on maps. The Soviet Union 
trained its astronauts here to fight on the highest battlefield of the 
cold war: space.

Yet these days, Star City is the place for America’s hard-won orbital 
partnership with Russia, where astronauts train to fly aboard Soyuz 
spacecraft. And in two years Star City will be the only place to send 
astronauts from any nation to the International Space Station.

The gap is coming: from 2010, when the National Aeronautics and Space 
Administration shuts down the space shuttle program, to 2015, when the 
next generation of American spacecraft is scheduled to arrive, NASA 
expects to have no human flight capacity and will depend on Russia to 
get to the $100 billion station, buying seats on Soyuz craft as space 
tourists do.

As NASA celebrates its 50th anniversary this month, the time lag in the 
Bush administration’s plan to retire the nation’s three space shuttles 
and work on a return to the Moon has thrust the United States space 
program squarely into national politics and geopolitical controversy.

Senators John McCain and Barack Obama have denounced the gap and 
promoted their commitment to the space program while on trips to 
Florida, where thousands of workers will lose their jobs when the 
shuttle program ends. And antagonism between the United States and 
Russia, over the conflict in Georgia and other issues, is clouding the 
future of a 15-year partnership in space, precisely when NASA will be 
more reliant on Russia than ever before.

The administrator of NASA, Michael D. Griffin, has called the situation 
“unseemly in the extreme.” In an e-mail message he sent to his top 
advisers in August, Dr. Griffin wrote that “events have unfolded in a 
way that makes it clear how unwise it was for the U.S. to adopt a policy 
of deliberate dependence on another power.”

Dr. Griffin is worried enough that he ordered his staff to explore 
flying the aging shuttles past 2010. He did so, he said in an interview 
last month, “about five minutes after the Russians invaded Georgia, 
because I could see this coming.” But he warned that any extension would 
be costly and could further delay NASA’s return to the Moon and threaten 
America’s role as the leading space power.

China’s Gains

Last month, China made the third successful launching of its Shenzhou 
VII spacecraft and the first spacewalk by one of its astronauts. The 
Chinese government has said it hopes to establish a space station and 
eventually make a Moon landing. The United States plans to return to the 
Moon by 2020 at the earliest; some observers believe China might get 
there first.

The interruption in American-controlled access to space rankles some in 
Washington, including Senator Bill Nelson of Florida, a leading 
proponent of the space program. In an interview, Mr. Nelson said it was 
“inexcusable” for the country’s space program to be put in a position of 
dependence on such a politically volatile partner. “We’ve got a Russian 
prime minister who believes he’s czar,” he said of Vladimir Putin, 
referring to Russia’s military action in Georgia.

The United States has had periods in which its astronauts could not 
reach space: from the end of the Apollo program in 1975 to the beginning 
of shuttle flights in 1981, and for more than two years after the loss 
of the shuttles Challenger in 1986 and Columbia in 2003. But the coming 
interval could be the longest if the rollout of NASA’s new rockets is 
significantly delayed.

Even though the outlines of the gap have been known since soon after Dr. 
Griffin began running the agency in 2005, Cmdr. Scott J. Kelly of the 
Navy, an astronaut who has made two trips to orbit, warned in April that 
the prospect of a United States that could not send humans into space on 
its own rockets would come as a shock. “A large part of the American 
public is going to be surprised,” he said, adding that people would cry, 
“Who let that happen?”

The Politics

The Bush administration chose to give up the nation’s own access to 
space for five years and move to the next phase of space travel. The 
administration decided to retire the shuttles and in January 2004 
announced a sweeping “vision for space exploration.”

Under the plan, NASA would stop using the aging and risky shuttle fleet 
and move to a new launching program, Constellation, built around Ares 
rockets and Orion capsules that are designed to return astronauts to the 
Moon and even to explore near-Earth asteroids and Mars.

To get from one program to the other without inflating NASA’s $17 
billion annual budget, the administration decided to wind down the 
shuttle program and ramp up Constellation. The decision has always been 
portrayed as difficult, but in recent months, criticism has flared. The 
Republican and Democratic presidential candidates, for example, have 
pledged to keep America flying.

“As president, I will act to ensure our astronauts will continue to 
explore space, and not just by hitching a ride with someone else,” Mr. 
McCain said in a statement this year. Mr. Obama has criticized what he 
has called the “poor planning and inadequate funding” that have led to 
the situation.

Both candidates say NASA should explore the continuation of the shuttle 
program for at least one additional flight and try to speed up the 
development of Constellation with more financing.

Any new money, though, would come too late to greatly shorten the 
development time for the new craft. “It is essentially unfixable now,” 
Dr. Griffin said. His growing frustration was clear in his e-mail 
message to aides on Aug. 18, which included the order to study the 
additional flights.

“In a rational world, we would have been allowed to pick a shuttle 
retirement date to be consistent with Ares/Orion availability,” Dr. 
Griffin wrote. Within the administration, he wrote, “retiring the 
shuttle is a jihad rather than an engineering and program management 
decision.”

After the message was published by The Orlando Sentinel, Dr. Griffin 
issued a statement saying his message had failed “to provide the 
contextual framework for my remarks, and my support for the 
administration’s policies.”

At the time, legislation vital to NASA’s gap plans — permission by 
Congress to buy Soyuz seats after 2011 — was stalled by the furor over 
the Russian action in Georgia. That problem was resolved last month when 
Congress quietly granted approval, but the broader issues presented by 
the gap remain. And Dr. Griffin’s concerns do not end with Russia and 
Washington politics. He has repeatedly warned that China’s space program 
is moving forward rapidly.

In testimony to the Senate last year, Dr. Griffin said it was likely 
that “China will be able to put people on the Moon before we will be 
able to get back.” That prospect concerns Representative Tom Feeney, 
Republican of Florida. A fellow congressman recently suggested naming 
the first new lunar base after Neil Armstrong. Mr. Feeney recalled 
responding, “What makes you think the Chinese are going to give us 
permission to name their base after one of our astronauts?”

The Partnership

The growing tension with Russia complicates a longstanding international 
alliance in space that helped defuse the cold war, especially among 
those who had served at the front lines.

William M. Shepherd, the first commander of the station and a former 
member of the Navy Seals, recalled that when he and his crewmate Yuri 
Gidzenko first orbited the Earth, the two cold warriors pointed to bases 
where, years before, they had trained and waited on alert.

“I realized at that moment we were not an American and a Russian any 
more,” Mr. Shepherd said.” “It was about something that transcended that 
whole canvas.”

The partnership began in the 1990s, as the Soviet Union and its economy 
collapsed and Russian knowledge about carrying people into orbit — or 
bombs to distant destinations — was at risk of falling into the hands of 
hostile nations. In paying to help keep the Russian space program going, 
the logic went, the United States would limit arms proliferation. By the 
mid-1990s Americans began serving aboard the Mir space station as the 
United States and Russia planned what would become the International 
Space Station.

The early days were marked by wariness. Mark Bowman, an early contract 
employee in Russia who is now back in Moscow as a NASA representative, 
said that Korolev, where mission control is, “was a closed city” when he 
arrived in 1993. “Foreigners were not allowed here,” Mr. Bowman said.

These days, teams of NASA workers live year round in Russia and dozens 
of others come through for training runs, launchings and landings. “I’d 
venture to say the people who work at NASA know the Russians better than 
any other branch of our government,” Commander Kelly, the astronaut, said.

Susan Eisenhower, an expert on United States-Russia relations and the 
space programs, said the Russians proved after the loss of the shuttle 
Columbia that they would hold up their end of the bargain by continuing 
to take Americans to the station. “When we had no choice because of the 
shuttle failure the Russian could have blackmailed us around this 
tragedy and did not do so,” Ms. Eisenhower said.

Vitaly Davidov, the deputy director of Roscosmos, the Russian space 
agency, said in an interview at mission control that Russia would honor 
its commitments to fly crews to the station.

That does not mean the going will be easy. The United States and Russia 
are at loggerheads over many trade and political issues. But Michael 
Krepon, who helped found the Henry L. Stimson Center, a policy 
institute, said that while the Russian space monopoly created risk, 
“there is a longstanding etiquette: you do not mess with the safety of 
humans in space.”

“I don’t think this is going to get very ugly if the gap problem 
continues,” Mr. Krepon said. “But it will become expensive.”

================================
George Antunes, Political Science Dept
University of Houston; Houston, TX 77204 
Voice: 713-743-3923  Fax: 713-743-3927
Mail: antunes at uh dot edu

*******************************
* POST TO [EMAIL PROTECTED] *
*******************************

Medianews mailing list
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
http://lists.etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews

Reply via email to