Cover Story: Will DSL Survive?
While Cable Modems Dominate, DSL Struggles to Catch Up

By Mike Farrell
Multichannel News

11/15/2008 7:58:00 AM

http://www.multichannel.com/index.asp?layout=articlePrint&articleID=CA6614961


Back in the late 1990s, the phone companies were quick to oblige 
Internet surfers with a product they call DSL, short for its lackluster 
name: “digital subscriber line.”

It quickly became a hot seller, and was briefly considered a threat to 
cable modems. But in a few short years, as consumer demand was met by 
the superior speeds offered by cable operators, DSL's growth trajectory 
plunged.

Today, DSL claims 30 million U.S. subscribers and few doubt that it's 
growth days are over. The number of new customers fell from a peak of 
4.15 million additions in the second quarter of 2006 to 1.46 million 
additions in second-quarter 2008, according to a recent research report 
by investment firm Sanford Bernstein.

By comparison, cable-modem customers numbered 35.3 million in the second 
quarter, and cable outpaced DSL in terms of net subscriber additions by 
more than a 3-to-1 margin — 671,426 net additions for cable versus 
215,514 for the telephone companies.

“So the elephant in the room is, what are the telephone companies going 
to do now that we're getting 75% share or whatever the share was last 
quarter? I think the answer is there's nothing they can do, because the 
problem isn't price,” Comcast chief operating officer Steve Burke said 
at the Merrill Lynch Fall Media Preview conference in September.

At the time, Burke said that Comcast felt at an advantage because it was 
competing against DSL in most of its footprint at a time when consumers 
are seeking ever-faster speeds to download video and other applications. 
Showing his competitive side again, Burke said on Comcast's 
second-quarter conference call that the MSO's strong broadband results 
“continue to suggest, as some have said, that DSL may be the new 
dial-up,” a dig referring to the super-slow telephone wire still used by 
15 million subscribers.

DSL may be dying, but it certainly isn't dead. AT&T, which lost DSL 
customers in the second quarter, improved to 148,000 additions in the 
third quarter. And Verizon Communications also improved to a smaller 
loss of about 96,000 DSL customers in the third quarter in the same 
period. The three largest telcos — AT&T, Verizon and Qwest 
Communications International — had about 26 million DSL subscribers at 
the end of the second quarter, or about 88% of U.S. DSL subscribers, 
according to Leichtman Research Group,

DSL's decline stands as an unavoidable truth to the nation's telephone 
companies, which are racing to build fiber lines to compete with cable. 
In its second-quarter conference call with analysts, Verizon chief 
operating officer Denny Strigl admitted the company had focused more on 
its fiber-optic FiOS product than DSL, which he vowed to change. AT&T 
has also said it placed more emphasis on its fiber-to-the-curb network 
U-Verse, which has been a factor in the DSL decline.

The simple logic of DSL's downfall is speed. Compared to DSL's top speed 
of 7.1 Mbps and a low of 256 Kilobits per second, cable-modem service 
varies from a low of about 5 Mbps to 30 Mbps for “Power Boost” service. 
And several MSOs are in the middle of rolling out DOCSIS 3.0 high-speed 
networks that will offer speeds of about 50 Mbps — Comcast expects 20% 
of its footprint to be DOCSIS 3.0-capable by the end of this year.

Those speeds are matched by Verizon's FiOS product — between 30 Megabits 
per second and 50 Mbps — and AT&T's U-Verse, which comes in around the 
middle with a maximum speed of 18 Mbps. But for the vast majority of the 
telco footprint, DSL will be the only telco option for high-speed 
Internet service.

The belief that every Internet user will be hungry for more bandwidth 
speed is a misplaced one, said Leichtman Research principal Bruce 
Leichtman, who doesn't believe that an explosion in video downloads has 
created a huge demand for speed. He cited research which states that the 
average U.S. consumer spends less than eight minutes per day downloading 
video.

“People are getting way too carried away with that,” Leichtman said.

Indeed, telephone companies may find a niche in customers who have no 
need for speed. Verizon spokesman Bob Elek said that consistency of 
service is more important to his customers than speed.

“It's not the demand for speed as much as it is a demand for 
consistency,” Elek said. “With a DSL connection, you can sit down and 
you're going to get very consistent performance out of that connection 
up to or at the speed it's advertised at. The shared cable-modem 
architecture doesn't generally produce that. It can, but you certainly 
can't be getting online when a lot of other people are online as well.”

While that argument has been used by telcos for years, Leichtman said 
that as the industry has matured, new customers have different priorities.

“When you're the 66 millionth customer, there's a reason why you've held 
out so long. Fifteen Mbps, 50 Mbps, you don't care about that,” 
Leichtman said. “What you care about is does it work, that it has a good 
value.”

The telcos are counting on the continued relevance of DSL for many 
reasons, but perhaps the most important one is that for most of its 
footprint, it will be the only broadband product it can offer. According 
to Sanford Bernstein's Craig Moffett, Verizon plans to build its FiOS 
fiber network to reach 18 million homes by 2010, leaving 15 million 
homes to DSL. AT&T expects its U-Verse network will touch 30 million 
homes by 2012, leaving 22 million households fiber-free.

After accounting for all the homes expected to be reached by fiber, 
about 71.5 million households — or 60% of the country — will not be 
directly connected to fiber, according to Sanford Bernstein. “In the 
majority of the U.S. — and by a large margin — the telcos are betting on 
legacy DSL,” said Moffett.

Moffett points out that cable's broadband advantage didn't just happen 
in the first half of this year. “The shift towards cable — and away from 
DSL, in particular — is no longer a question, and indeed is now more 
than two and a half years old,” Moffett wrote.

Perhaps the telephone industry's greatest concern is access-line losses, 
which totaled 2.3 million in the last quarter. Although telcos argue 
that those losses are former wireline customers who've cut the cord and 
switched exclusively to cellphones, Moffett argues that about two-thirds 
of access-line disconnects represent defections to cable.

“As more consumers disconnect their telco phone lines, there are fewer 
and fewer left to subscribe to DSL,” he wrote.

Access-line losses started to become a major issue for the telcos just 
as cable began offering its own voice service. Residential access lines 
at the major telcos have dwindled from 101.8 million in 2003 — when 
Cablevision Systems began offering the first $90 triple-play package — 
to 72.4 million in the second quarter, according to Sanford Bernstein.

“Cable bundling their service with phone has absolutely helped them,” 
Leichtman said. “Cable has phone available to over 100 million 
households. They can tie the broadband into those 100 million 
households. Phone has fiber available to 20 to 25 million [households]. 
That's the big difference.”

But Leichtman said the decline in DSL subscriber additions in the past 
was mainly due to a conscious decision by the telcos to not pursue 
less-profitable customers. “What happened in the last two quarters 
wasn't that cable suddenly got faster,” Leichtman said. “It was that the 
telcos stopped going after the low, low end.”

Leichtman added that the telcos realized that the game wasn't about 
gaining share at any cost, it is about gaining high-quality customers.

“If DSL is killed, it is a self-inflicted wound,” Leichtman said.

To offset the losses, telcos are trying to boost DSL speeds and package 
the service differently. Just last week, AT&T kicked up the speed of its 
highest-tier DSL service by 80%, introducing a broadband service with 18 
Mbps downloads available only to customers who also subscribe to its 
U-verse TV. Previously, its fastest retail offering has provided up to 
10 Mbps downstream.

The new 18 Mbps service is an attempt to squeeze the last ounces of 
juice from DSL and should be some help in stopping customers from 
fleeing to cable-modem services, according to analysts. While AT&T 
expects to see continued gains in DSL, the telco said it is also 
providing customers with several options, including wireless.

AT&T spokeswoman Jenny Bridges noted that AT&T added 2.8 million 
wireless customers with broadband-capable devices in the third quarter 
and that the telco bundles free Wi-Fi connectivity with its broadband 
and Laptop Connect plans, among others.

Telcos are also starting to borrow a page from the cable playbook with 
DSL, bundling it in different tiers with satellite video and voice 
service. AT&T began offering a so-called “naked DSL” product in October 
— one that does not require the subscriber to buy a separate phone line 
— that it said is proving to be popular with customers.

In early November, Verizon cut prices on DSL, phone and DirecTV bundles 
and expanded the availability of its fastest DSL tier. The telco 
introduced an entry-level triple play — 1 Mbps DSL, phone and 150 
channels of video for $79.99 per month. It also dropped the price of 
some of its other DSL bundles by as much as $18 per month.

In addition, Verizon nearly doubled the availability of its highest 
speed DSL service — with download speeds up to 7.1 Mbps — to 6.6 million 
homes, versus 3.4 million homes in June.

The telco boosted the speeds of its entry-level DSL Internet service to 
1 Mbps downstream and 384 Kbps upstream, up from 768 Kbps/128 Kbps, and 
is offering the service for $9.99 per month for the first six months 
with a one-year contract. After the six-month promotional period, 
monthly pricing for the remainder of the annual plan will range from 
$19.99 to $25.99, depending on the market.

Verizon just started offering the lower-priced bundles, said Elek, so 
it's too early to gauge their success. But so far, “it looks pretty 
good,” he said.

But Elek stopped short of predicting that the tide has turned completely 
for DSL.

“I don't know for sure,” Elek said. “The market changes from quarter to 
quarter. We still think it's an extremely viable product for us and our 
consumers. But cable is going to have its successes too. It's a very 
competitive industry.”

-- 
================================
George Antunes, Political Science Dept
University of Houston; Houston, TX 77204 
Voice: 713-743-3923  Fax: 713-743-3927
Mail: antunes at uh dot edu

***********************************
* POST TO [email protected] *
***********************************

Medianews mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews

Reply via email to