November 17, 2008

Burned Once, Intel Prepares New Chip Fortified by Constant Tests
By JOHN MARKOFF
NY Times

http://www.nytimes.com/2008/11/17/technology/companies/17chip.html?ref=business&pagewanted=print


HILLSBORO, Ore. — Rows and rows of computers in Intel’s labs here 
relentlessly torture-tested the company’s new microprocessor for months 
on end.

But on a recent tour of the labs, John Barton, an Intel vice president 
in charge of product testing, acknowledged that he was still feeling 
anxious about the possibility of a last-minute, show-stopping flaw.

After all, even the slightest design error in the chip could end up 
being a billion-dollar mistake.

“I’m not sleeping well yet,” Mr. Barton said.

Intel’s Core i7 microprocessor, code-named Nehalem, which goes on sale 
Monday, has already received glowing technical reviews. But it is 
impossible for Mr. Barton to predict exactly how the chip will function 
in thousands of computers running tens of thousands of programs.

The design and testing of an advanced microprocessor chip is among the 
most complex of all human endeavors. To ensure that its products are as 
error-free as possible, Intel, based in Santa Clara, Calif., now spends 
a half-billion dollars annually in its factories around the world, 
testing the chips for more than a year before selling them.

There is good reason for the caution. In 1994, the giant chip maker was 
humbled by a tiny error in the floating point calculation unit of its 
Pentium chips. The flaw, which led to an embarrassing recall, prompted a 
wrenching cultural shift at the company, which had minimized the testing 
requirements of the Pentium.

A series of bugs last year in the Barcelona microprocessor from Intel’s 
main competitor, Advanced Micro Devices, was equally devastating.

A.M.D., based in Sunnyvale, Calif., had been making steady progress, 
offering new processor technologies long before Intel and handily 
winning the power-efficiency war. But the quality problems that slammed 
A.M.D. cost the company revenue for several quarters and landed it in a 
hole from which it has yet to dig out.

If Nehalem is a hit for Intel, it will represent vindication for Andrew 
Grove, the company’s former chief, who acknowledged that he had been 
blindsided by the Pentium problems and then set out to reform the company.

The Pentium bug badly damaged Intel’s brand with consumers. The company 
quickly became a laughingstock as jokes made the rounds of the Internet: 
Q: Know how the Republicans can cut taxes and pay the deficit at the 
same time? A: Their spreadsheet runs on a Pentium computer.

After initially appearing to stonewall, Intel reversed course and issued 
an apology while setting aside $420 million to pay for the recall.

The company put Mr. Grove’s celebrated remark about the situation on key 
chains: “Bad companies are destroyed by crisis. Good companies survive 
them. Great companies are improved by them.”

Those words weigh heavily on the shoulders of Mr. Barton and his 
colleagues — as does the pressure from Intel’s customers around the 
world whose very survival is based on the ability to create new products 
with the company’s chips at their heart. Nehalem is initially aimed at 
desktop computers, but the company hopes it will eventually be found in 
everything from powerful servers to laptops.

“Our business model is now predicated on saying to the consumer, ‘You 
will get a new set of functionality by a particular date,’ ” Mr. Barton 
said. “We did get a new dimension of business pressure that says we 
can’t take our merry time turning it out whenever we feel like it.”

The pressure for a successful product is especially intense now as the 
overall technology industry faces a serious slump. Intel’s chief 
executive, Paul S. Otellini, said last month that the company was 
getting “mixed signals” from customers about future spending. Intel’s 
stock fell 7.7 percent on Friday to $13.32, a six-year low, in a broad 
market drop.

With Nehalem, Intel’s designers took the company’s previous generation 
of chips and added a host of features, each of which adds complexity and 
raises the possibility of unpredictable interactions.

“Now we are hitting systemic complexity,” said Aart de Geus, chief 
executive of Synopsys, a Silicon Valley developer of chip design tools. 
“Things that came from different angles that used to be independent have 
become interdependent.”

Trying to define the complexity that Mr. Barton and his team face is 
itself a challenge. Even in the late 1970s, chips were being designed 
that were as complicated as the street map of a large city.

Mr. Barton’s love affair with the world of electronics began as a child, 
when he took apart a walkie-talkie his father had given him and counted 
its transistors: a total of seven. The change in his lifetime, he said, 
has been “mind-boggling.”

Going from the Intel 8088 — the processor used in the IBM PC 27 years 
ago — to the Nehalem involves a jump from 29,000 transistors to 731 
million, on a silicon chip roughly the same size.

Mr. Barton equates the two by comparing a city the size of Ithaca, N.Y., 
to the continent of Europe. “Ithaca is quite complex in its own right if 
you think of all that goes on,” he said. “If we scale up the population 
to 730 million, we come to Europe as about the right size. Now take 
Europe and shrink it until it all fits in about the same land mass as 
Ithaca.”

Even given a lifetime, it would be impossible to test more than the 
smallest fraction of the total possible “states” that the Nehalem chip 
can be programmed in, which are easily more plentiful than all the atoms 
in the universe.

Modern designers combat complexity by turning to modular design 
techniques, making it possible to simplify drastically what needs to be 
tested.

“Instead of testing for every possible case, you break up the problem 
into smaller pieces,” said G. Dan Hutcheson, chief executive of VLSI 
Research, a semiconductor consulting firm.

After the Pentium flaw, Intel also fundamentally rethought the way it 
designed its processors, trying to increase the chance that its chips 
would be error-free even before testing. During the late 1990s it turned 
to a group of mathematical theoreticians in the computer science field 
who had developed advanced techniques for evaluating hardware and 
software, known as formal methods.

“For several years Intel hired everyone in the world in formal methods,” 
said Pat Lincoln, director of SRI International’s Computer Science 
Laboratory.

The Intel designers have also done something else to help defend against 
the errors that will inevitably sneak into the chip. Nehalem contains a 
significant amount of software that can be changed even after the 
microprocessor leaves the factory. That gives the designers a huge 
safety net.

It is one that Mr. Barton and his team are hoping they will not have to use.

-- 
================================
George Antunes, Political Science Dept
University of Houston; Houston, TX 77204 
Voice: 713-743-3923  Fax: 713-743-3927
Mail: antunes at uh dot edu

***********************************
* POST TO [email protected] *
***********************************

Medianews mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews

Reply via email to