December 12, 2008

As Buyout Fails, Bell Canada Seeks to Bolster a Struggling Business
By IAN AUSTEN
NY Times

http://www.nytimes.com/2008/12/12/business/worldbusiness/12bell.html?_r=1&ref=business&pagewanted=print


OTTAWA — With the record-setting $50 billion leveraged buyout of Bell 
Canada all over except for the potential litigation, the company, 
Canada’s largest telecommunications company, once again faces a possibly 
bigger issue: reversing the seemingly relentless decline of its business.

The takeover, which had several setbacks, appeared doomed late last 
month after the accounting firm KPMG concluded that Bell, which trades 
under the corporate name B.C.E., would not be solvent after being 
burdened with about $30 billion in debt from the deal.

Its demise was confirmed on Thursday through two curt statements. The 
buyout group, which was led by the Ontario Teachers’ Pension Plan, said 
that the deal’s failure to pass its solvency test was the final blow, 
adding: “Under these circumstances neither party owes a termination fee 
to the other.”

In its statement, Bell questioned the buyers’ right to terminate the 
deal just over 24 hours before its expiration time and said that it 
would demand a $1.2 billion break-up fee. “All closing conditions have 
been satisfied by B.C.E., other than the solvency opinion, a condition 
to closing that was to be satisfied by its nature at the effective 
time,” the company wrote.

But as lawyers for both sides prepared to settle that question, many 
analysts said that Bell was now better positioned to deal with the 
future than it would have been after a buyout.

“This announcement today is probably the best news Bell can hear,” said 
Brahm Eiley, a principal at the Convergence Consulting Group, a 
telecommunications analysis firm based in Toronto. “They were going to 
be saddled with a debt which would have meant that they could not have 
done anything.”

Bell is a humbled giant. It is now the No. 3 player in Canada’s wireless 
market behind Rogers Communications, which also leads the cable 
television business, and Telus, the dominant telephone company in 
Alberta and British Columbia.

Bell’s satellite television service has always lagged well behind cable. 
And Rogers in Ontario, along with Vidéotron in Quebec, are now poaching 
about 10 percent of Bell’s traditional local phone customers a year. Mr. 
Eiley estimates that cable companies now provide about one-quarter of 
Canada’s local telephone service after entering the business in 2004.

Bell’s sole remaining area of dominance is providing services to 
businesses and governments, although fierce competition from Telus in 
that segment has lowered its profitability.

While the takeover has collapsed, it did have one effect on Bell. At the 
request of the buyers, George Cope, a former Telus executive, was 
appointed as the company’s chief executive in July, replacing Michael J. 
Sabia.

Mr. Cope’s early steps have not dealt with the company’s broad strategic 
issues. Instead he has mainly focused on cost cutting, eliminating 2,750 
mostly middle management jobs and introducing a new logo and advertising 
campaign for the company.

Many of Bell’s most pressing problems date back to the technology boom 
of the late 1990s. At that time, Bell focused on media company 
acquisitions rather than on network upgrades. It paid premium prices 
for, among other things, Canada’s largest private television network, 
CTV, and control of The Globe and Mail newspaper.

Mr. Sabia came in and unwound the company’s media foray. But while 
Rogers can now compete with Bell in all of its consumer product areas 
including wireless, Bell’s aging network means that the company is fast 
losing ground in the Internet and television businesses.

Bell never fulfilled plans to start selling television through an 
upgraded wired network about three years ago. That leaves it offering 
only a satellite television service. Because Canada is far north of the 
equator, where the system’s satellites orbit, many potential customers 
are unable to receive it.

At the same time, Rogers and Vidéotron, a unit of the publisher and 
broadcaster Quebecor, are increasingly offering Internet services in 
some areas that offer speeds well beyond Bell’s service.

Vidéotron has also recently won approval, along with three other 
companies, to compete in the wireless market.

Troy Crandall, a telecommunications analyst with MacDougall, MacDougall 
and MacTier in Montreal, expects that Bell will be forced to make 
substantial network investments.

“Sure it’s expensive,” he said. “But if they continue on the way they 
were going, we’re going to see cable making more inroads while the new 
wireless entrants take the low end of their market.”

Mr. Eiley cautions that both Bell and Telus, which he said faced several 
of the same problems as Bell, would have to weigh carefully the 
potential returns from investments in network upgrades. That situation, 
he added, might delay or even block substantial change.

“Bell could just muddle along for a pretty long time,” he said. “You can 
run your business that way, but you end up being a much smaller player.”

-- 
================================
George Antunes, Political Science Dept
University of Houston; Houston, TX 77204 
Voice: 713-743-3923  Fax: 713-743-3927
Mail: antunes at uh dot edu

***********************************
* POST TO [email protected] *
***********************************

Medianews mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews

Reply via email to